Judge orders three taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads pulled, finding them likely partisan
Judge Jennifer Rochon declined to block most of the challenged videos. Government lawyers say they cannot comply with the part of her order covering MAGA Inc.

A federal judge in Manhattan on Friday, Oct. 30, ordered the Trump administration to take down three videos from government websites and social media accounts. She found that they were likely partisan advertising paid for with public money. The order also tells the government to cancel any arrangements for the ads to air through "authorized third parties, including airing of the advertisements by MAGA Inc.," the president's main super PAC. Hours later, government lawyers asked the judge to drop that part, saying the administration does not control MAGA Inc. and cannot comply.
The ruling, by U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York, came four days before the Nov. 3 midterm elections. It covers three of more than a dozen ads the plaintiffs challenged. Rochon declined to block the rest, at least for now, and said the government was likely to win on many of them.
The case raises a question that Congress, the Government Accountability Office and past administrations have dealt with for decades: where a president's legitimate effort to explain and defend his policies ends and taxpayer-funded campaigning begins.
What the order requires#
Rochon's written order, entered at 3:20 p.m. Friday, bars the defendants from disseminating three ads titled "$5,000 to Americans," "Every Democrat Voted Against No Tax on Tips" and "Cost of Socialism." It requires them to:
- remove the three ads immediately from official government websites, "including social media sites such as YouTube, Instagram, or other similar sites";
- cancel "any slots, placements, reservations, or arrangements" for airing the ads through authorized third parties, including MAGA Inc.;
- serve a copy of the order on MAGA Inc.; and
- file a status report confirming compliance within 24 hours.
The order lasts 14 days unless extended. The defendants are the Department of Homeland Security, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, the Office of Management and Budget, its director Russell Vought, the Executive Office of the President and White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles. President Donald Trump is not a defendant.
Rochon found that the plaintiffs had shown "a clear and substantial likelihood of success on the merits of their ultra vires claim" for at least three ads. An ultra vires claim argues that officials acted beyond the authority Congress gave them.
What the ads say#
Courthouse News Service reported that Rochon explained her reasoning from the bench after an emergency hearing. In the 33-second "$5,000 to Americans" video, Trump speaks from the Oval Office. "If the Democrats win, you will have an economic depression," he says. "If the Republicans win, you will each have $5,000 in your pocket."
Rochon said she was "hard pressed" to see the message as anything other than a call to support Republicans. "Voters are being directly asked to support one political party over another in an upcoming election," she said, according to Courthouse News. She called the "No Tax on Tips" ad, which features photos of Democratic members of Congress, "a classic partisan advertisement." She said "Cost of Socialism" criticized candidates affiliated with the Democratic Socialists of America and contained "a call to action, urging voters to steer clear of candidates aligned with the agenda."
The judge played one ad in court and asked Assistant U.S. Attorney Jeffrey Oestericher to explain why it was not purely partisan. Oestericher argued it lawfully communicated the president's policies, Courthouse News reported.
"This court can neither postpone an election nor turn back the clock," Rochon said, according to the Associated Press, as published by PBS. She also said she could restore the ads or block others after hearing more evidence.
How the case got here#
The suit was filed Oct. 7, NBC News reported. The plaintiffs are the watchdog group Common Cause; Robert Hunter, a Democratic candidate for the Alabama state House; and SEIU Local 32BJ and its political action committee. The suit initially targeted television ads paid for by DHS.
According to Rochon's Oct. 12 opinion, the money came from a $6.168 billion appropriation to U.S. Customs and Border Protection in the 2025 reconciliation law, Public Law 119-21. One listed use was "commemorating efforts and events related to border security." On Sept. 19, CBP asked OMB to make an additional $20 million available for "commemorative events." OMB approved the request less than two hours later. The next day CBP issued a $20 million purchase order for a "National Media Campaign" to an outside vendor.
In that earlier phase, the opinion says, the government "did not contest" that the ad placements were paid for with border-security funds and did not dispute that the use violated the Purpose Act and the appropriations law. It argued instead that the case was moot and the plaintiffs lacked standing. Rochon rejected those arguments and issued a temporary restraining order on Oct. 11. A later order directed the government to explain why challenged ads aired on Oct. 12 "given the contrary representations made by counsel."
The plaintiffs then said the White House had moved the effort to other channels. In their Oct. 23 motion, they said that a day after the first order, the Executive Office of the President posted new political ads to the White House YouTube page, and that MAGA Inc. then began airing some on national television. They said the government admitted in discovery that White House staff helped "compil[e]" the ads.
The government's argument#
The Justice Department's opposition brief, filed Oct. 27, made three main points.
First, it said the president "has the right to inform the public about his policies and to rebut attacks on those policies and his Administration," and that White House staff support that function. It quoted the GAO's guide to appropriations law, known as the Red Book, which says that restricting "all materials that have some political content or express support of an Administration's policies would significantly curtail" that legitimate role.
Second, it argued that White House staff time is not a "use" of appropriated funds in the sense the law means. Salaries were already appropriated, the brief said, and no new money was spent. It noted that Congress has written explicit salary bans elsewhere when it wanted to.
Third, it said the court cannot order relief against MAGA Inc., a nonparty, or against the president. The brief also warned that the plaintiffs' theory could invite courts to review presidential speeches for partisanship, which it said would raise "serious separation of powers concerns."
On the "$5,000" ad specifically, the government argued that it "informs the general public of a new monetary proposal as well as the Administration's views on tax policy."
After the ruling, the government filed a letter asking Rochon to remove the MAGA Inc. provision. "Defendants cannot comply with this aspect of the TRO because the named Defendants cannot control MAGA, Inc.," it said, adding that the plaintiffs could have named MAGA Inc. as a party and did not. The AP, in a report carried by LiveNOW from Fox, said Rochon had not yet ruled on that request.
White House spokesperson Lauren Bis said, "This Biden-appointed activist judge issued a lawless order to stop the administration from sharing patriotic videos," according to the AP. Rochon was nominated by President Joe Biden; the AP also noted that she once clerked for Trump's late sister, Judge Maryanne Trump Barry.
The plaintiffs' argument#
The plaintiffs relied on two laws. The Purpose Act, 31 U.S.C. § 1301, requires agencies to spend money only for the purposes Congress set. Section 718 of the annual financial services appropriations law bars the use of funds "for publicity or propaganda purposes" not authorized by Congress.
In their reply brief, they wrote that "Congress did not appropriate funds to EOP to run a PR shop to help the President's allies and attack his perceived ideological opponents." They cited the GAO's view that the propaganda ban covers three categories: "self-aggrandizement, covert propaganda, and purely partisan materials." On the staff-time question, they cited a 2026 District of Columbia ruling, Neguse v. ICE, which held that the time officials spend on a barred activity "constitutes a use of funds."
"This temporary restraining order will stop the administration's wanton disregard for the law while the court hears the full case," said Bradley Girard of Democracy Forward, one of the plaintiffs' law firms, according to the AP. Common Cause President Virginia Kase Solomón said the court "rightfully recognized this scheme for what it was: an unlawful attempt to use public funds for partisan propaganda right in the middle of an election," Courthouse News reported.
Criticism has crossed party lines#
Objections to the ads have not come only from Democrats. In a Sept. 27 interview on CBS's "Face the Nation," Sen. John Kennedy, a Louisiana Republican, said, "I don't think any public official, including President Trump or Kristi Noem or John Kennedy, should spend public money … on private ads for themselves," the Guardian reported. "Now, the White House sees it differently," he added, saying there "probably is a rule" against it.$
The White House has defended the ads as public service announcements akin to those past administrations made to promote their policies, the AP reported. Its lawyers also argue that judges should be wary of policing political content in executive communications. The GAO standard the plaintiffs invoke itself recognizes that an administration may "justify its policies and ... rebut attacks on its policies." Rochon appeared to accept part of that argument when she declined to block most of the challenged ads, the AP reported.
Weighing the arguments#
Several of the disputes here are about legal standards rather than facts. The government does not appear to dispute what the ads say. The question is whether content that names a party and urges voters to choose it falls inside or outside a president's power to inform the public.
The government's "speeches" argument raises a real line-drawing problem, but it is partly a slippery-slope argument: a ruling about paid video ads on official channels does not by itself reach a presidential address. The plaintiffs' argument also has a gap the court has not resolved. Whether staff time spent "compiling" ads counts as a "use" of funds is contested, and the main authority they cite is a single district court decision.
The White House statement described the judge rather than the legal reasoning; that is a response about the decision-maker, not the merits. The plaintiffs' statements, for their part, describe the ads as a "scheme," a characterization the court has not adopted beyond its preliminary finding about three ads.
The MAGA Inc. provision is the most legally uncertain part of the order. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65, an injunction binds the parties and others "in active concert or participation" with them. Whether a super PAC fits that description has not been decided in this case.
Deadlines and hearings ahead#
- Saturday, Oct. 31, about 3:20 p.m. ET: The government's compliance report is due, 24 hours after the order was entered.
- Pending: Rochon's ruling on the government's request to remove the MAGA Inc. provision. The government could also appeal to the Second Circuit.
- Tuesday, Nov. 3: Election Day.
- Nov. 13: Friday's 14-day order expires unless extended.
- Nov. 13, 2 p.m.: The preliminary injunction hearing. Rochon rescheduled it from Nov. 10 at the government's request, and the first restraining order was extended on consent to Nov. 20.
The ads case is one of several in which judges have pushed back on administration actions in the final week before the election. Our report on Judge Trina Thompson's order barring threats against election workers covers another. A separate dispute over government lawyers' statements to a court is described in our story on Judge Ana Reyes's inquiry into the East Potomac golf course case. For the campaign backdrop, see our guide to the midterms' final week and the latest generic ballot polling.
Funding note#
Trump is not on the ballot in 2026, and this story concerns the use of appropriated government funds, not campaign receipts. MAGA Inc. is a super PAC whose spending is reported to the Federal Election Commission separately from any candidate's campaign. 567 Politics checked its funding records for Trump on Oct. 31 and has no verified FEC snapshot on file for his profile. We did not review MAGA Inc.'s filings for this story, so no figures for its spending on these ads are included; missing data should not be read as zero. Our methodology explains how we handle contested claims.
Differing perspectives
Should the court expand its order on taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads to cover White House staff-made ads and those aired by MAGA Inc.?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Defendants are wrong at each turn
Who holds it: Common Cause, Robert Hunter, SEIU Local 32BJ and Empire State 32BJ SEIU PAC, plaintiffs
In their Oct. 29 reply, the moving plaintiffs write that the defendants "do not contest that Plaintiffs have standing," irreparable harm, or the balance of equities. They say the amended complaint covers ads posted to official channels and ads "compiled" by White House staff and later aired by MAGA Inc. They conclude: "Defendants are wrong at each turn."
In their words: Plaintiffs' reply in support of motion to expand the TRO, S.D.N.Y., Oct. 29, 2026 ↗
The President has the right to inform the public about his policies
Who holds it: Department of Homeland Security, Executive Office of the President, OMB and other defendants
In their Oct. 27 opposition, the defendants write that White House staff "perform duties to support the President. And the President has the right to inform the public about his policies and to rebut attacks on those policies and his Administration." They also argue that MAGA Inc., which is not a party, cannot be reached because plaintiffs' injury "is not redressable."
In their words: Defendants' memorandum opposing motion to expand the TRO, S.D.N.Y., Oct. 27, 2026 ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Judge orders three taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads pulled, finding them likely partisan.” 567politics. Published 2026-10-31. Updated 2026-11-02. https://www.567politics.com/news/judge-rochon-trump-administration-ads-propaganda-order-october-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Judge orders three taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads pulled, finding them likely partisan |url=https://www.567politics.com/news/judge-rochon-trump-administration-ads-propaganda-order-october-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-10-31 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://www.567politics.com/news/judge-rochon-trump-administration-ads-propaganda-order-october-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Judge orders three taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads pulled, finding them likely partisan",
"URL": "https://www.567politics.com/news/judge-rochon-trump-administration-ads-propaganda-order-october-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
10,
31
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://www.567politics.com/embed/news/judge-rochon-trump-administration-ads-propaganda-order-october-2026?theme=auto" title="Judge orders three taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads pulled, finding them likely partisan by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Judge orders three taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads pulled, finding them likely partisan by <a href="https://www.567politics.com/news/judge-rochon-trump-administration-ads-propaganda-order-october-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://www.567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Order, Common Cause v. Department of Homeland Security (Dkt. 101, Oct. 30) ↗
U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. (via CourtListener)
Judge Rochon's Oct. 30 order covering three ads and MAGA Inc.
- primary evidence
Opinion and order, Common Cause v. Department of Homeland Security (Dkt. 42) ↗
U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. (via CourtListener)
The Oct. 12 opinion on the DHS-funded ads and the $20 million reapportionment.
- primary evidence
Defendants' letter on the MAGA Inc. provision (Dkt. 102) ↗
U.S. Attorney's Office, S.D.N.Y.
Says the defendants cannot control a nonparty super PAC.
- right argument
Defendants' memorandum of law in opposition to plaintiffs' motion to expand the temporary restraining order (Dkt. 86) ↗
U.S. Department of Justice
The administration's case that the ads inform the public and that staff time is not a new use of funds.
- left argument
Plaintiffs' reply in support of motion to expand the temporary restraining order (Dkt. 95) ↗
Plaintiffs Common Cause, Robert Hunter, SEIU Local 32BJ and Empire State 32BJ SEIU PAC
Argues the ads are purely partisan materials barred by the publicity-or-propaganda rider.
- left argument
Plaintiffs' motion to expand the temporary restraining order (Dkt. 81) ↗
Plaintiffs' filing
Alleges the White House moved the ads to its own channels and MAGA Inc. after the first order.
- independent analysis
Judge orders 3 taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads to be pulled from TV, social media ↗
PBS News (Associated Press)
Wire report with White House and plaintiffs' statements.
- independent analysis
Judge blocks 3 MAGA ads over concerns they breached taxpayer-funded propaganda law ↗
Courthouse News Service
Courtroom account of the judge's bench ruling and the ads' content.
- independent analysis
Federal judge orders pro-Trump TV ads funded by taxpayers off air immediately ↗
NBC News
Report on the original Oct. 11 order and the plaintiffs.
- independent analysis
3 taxpayer-funded Trump administration ads must be taken down, judge rules ↗
LiveNOW from Fox (Associated Press)
Syndicated AP report noting the MAGA Inc. request was pending.
- other perspective
Republican senator criticizes White House for taxpayer-funded Trump ads ↗
The Guardian
Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) on CBS saying public money should not fund ads promoting officials.
Reviewed 2026-10-31. Discovery searches returned only generic 'judge' pages, so this list was built from court records and reporting opened while writing. The administration's case is represented by its own court filings; we did not find a published independent conservative analysis defending the ads' legality to add. Republican criticism is represented by Sen. John Kennedy's CBS interview as reported by the Guardian. The AP's own site could not be loaded, so its reporting is linked through PBS and LiveNOW from Fox syndications.