Judge opens inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court over Trump's golf course plan
Judge Ana Reyes says she will examine Justice and Interior lawyers' statements on East Potomac Golf Links, while stressing she has found no wrongdoing.

A federal judge in Washington said on Friday, October 30, that she is opening a formal inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court. The case is about the future of East Potomac Golf Links, a public golf course in Washington's East Potomac Park that President Donald Trump wants to rebuild as a championship course.
U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes announced the inquiry at the end of a long hearing. She stressed that opening it is not a finding of wrongdoing. The Justice Department said it would keep carrying out the president's agenda.
The case pits a preservation group and two local golfers against the Interior Department, the National Park Service and other federal defendants. It has turned into a dispute over a basic question: when did the government decide to close and redesign the course, and did its lawyers tell the court the truth about that?
What the judge announced#
Reyes is a judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. According to CBS News, she said she would examine whether officials and lawyers at the Justice and Interior Departments engaged in misconduct. CBS reported that she plans to run the inquiry herself, with help from a special master. A special master is a neutral person appointed by a court to help gather facts.
Bloomberg Law and MS NOW described the choice in slightly different terms. Both reported that Reyes said she could conduct the inquiry herself or have a special master do it. CBS reported that she has not yet named a special master and gave the Justice Department five days to object to the plan to appoint one.
The reports agree on the scope. MS NOW reported that the inquiry will look at whether lawyers made false statements, withheld testimony or interfered with witness testimony. Bloomberg Law reported that it will cover possible false statements, withheld information and other breaches of ethics rules.
CBS listed several specific questions the judge said she would examine:
- Whether a notice to the court about tree removal at the course was filed in bad faith.
- Whether government lawyers told Jessica Bowron, the acting director of the National Park Service, to leave certain information out of a sworn declaration about plans for the course.
- Whether government lawyers told Kevin Griess, superintendent of National Mall and Memorial Parks, to include certain budget information in a declaration.
- Whether Justice Department lawyers made accurate statements about plans to renovate the course.
Bloomberg Law reported that Reyes also ordered the government to preserve all documents and communications about the golf course planning process. She also ordered the Justice Department to give the names of everyone who worked on a design submission to a federal planning agency, according to the same report.
"For months the court has trusted but not verified," Reyes said, according to Bloomberg Law. "No longer."
Each outlet reported that Reyes emphasized she had made no finding that anyone broke the rules. An inquiry is a step to find out the facts. It is not a sanction.
The exchange with the Justice Department's third-ranking official#
Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward argued the government's side at the hearing. He is the third-ranking official at the Justice Department.
The judge pressed him on timing. The key dates are these:
- On October 18, Trump posted on Truth Social that the Interior Department had "developed a plan" with golf course architect Tom Fazio to build a new course on the site. He said the current course would close on November 15, according to Bloomberg Law and CBS News.
- On October 19, Woodward told the court in a hearing that "there is no plan to close the course," Bloomberg Law reported.
- On Monday, October 26, Trump posted again. CBS News quoted him as saying the administration was "closing the East Potomac Golf Course Site as scheduled on November 15th."
- On Wednesday, October 28, the Justice Department told the court that the course and nearby areas would close by November 15, according to Bloomberg Law and CBS News. MS NOW reported that Woodward said the Interior Department was "working to develop a plan" to close the course on or around that date.
On Friday, the judge asked Woodward whether the president's October 18 post meant what it said. MS NOW reported that Woodward said he could not know what the president meant and could not give an opinion on his choice of words.
Bloomberg Law reported that Woodward said he "didn't utter those words" when the judge asked whether he was telling the court not to believe the president. He said he objected to "hypothesizing" about what the president meant, according to the same report.
Bloomberg Law also reported that Woodward said the question "seems to fall squarely within the executive privilege." Executive privilege is a legal doctrine that can shield some presidential communications from disclosure. Reyes replied that this was "quite an extraordinary view of executive privilege," the outlet reported.
The judge was also concerned about a design submission. CBS reported that Woodward gave the court a rendering of a new course designed by Fazio. That design was submitted on Friday to the National Capital Planning Commission, a federal agency that reviews building plans in the capital region. Bloomberg Law reported that Woodward disclosed that the submission had been in the works for weeks.
MS NOW reported that Woodward said various renovation plans had been under consideration "for some time now." He also said he did not recall the court asking whether the government was preparing a submission to the commission.
"Are you kidding me right now? Seriously, Mr. Woodward, come on," Reyes said, according to Bloomberg Law. MS NOW reported a nearly identical version of the remark.
The government's position#
The Justice Department has defended its conduct and its legal position. After Friday's hearing, a department spokesperson told MS NOW: "The Department of Justice will not be deterred from executing on the President's agenda."
In court filings, the government has argued several points. These are summarized in Reyes's 70-page opinion of October 26:
- No final plan. For months, government lawyers said there was no final plan to overhaul the course. In an early filing, they said the Interior Department was only "entertaining" proposals. Bowron said in a sworn declaration that proposals were "still in the conceptual phase."
- Not yet reviewable. The government argued that even if a plan exists, it is not a "final agency action." Under federal law, courts generally review agency decisions only once they are final.
- Tree work as maintenance. The government argued that the tree removal was meant to return the course to its historic design, under a long-standing landscape report. It said thinning trees under that report and federal environmental law serves the public interest.
- Limits on courts. The government argued that the public has an interest in courts staying within their limits, including rules on standing and ripeness. It also cited the separation of powers and said courts should not intrude on presidential authority.
The Interior Department has made similar points in public. In an October statement to CNN, it said the Park Service was "finally implementing a 7-year-old plan to address tree overgrowth" at the course. "This carefully planned work is part of our required stewardship of the park," the statement said.
Griess, the park superintendent, said in a sworn filing in October that the tree work "is not a renovation or redesign of the Golf Course." He said it would be carried out "irrespective of any future renovation or redesign," according to CNN.
The plaintiffs' position#
The case was filed in February by the DC Preservation League and two golfers who play at East Potomac. They asked the court to block what they call the "Washington National Plan." According to the judge's opinion, the plaintiffs define it as a plan "to destroy East Potomac Golf Course and to build in its place a championship-style golf course suitable for professional tournaments."
The plaintiffs argue that the government has been carrying out that plan in pieces without the environmental review required by the National Environmental Policy Act. That law requires federal agencies to study the environmental effects of major projects before they act.
They also argue that the tree removal was a first step toward construction, not routine upkeep. In court, they said the government split one large project into smaller parts to avoid a full review, according to the judge's opinion.
The plaintiffs say the changes would harm them. According to the opinion, the golfers' declarations suggest that a redesigned course would cost more to play. The preservation league says it would lose the ability to host programs on the course and was shut out of the environmental review process.
How the case reached this point#
The judge declined to step in several times earlier this year. In March and April, the government told the court that no final plan existed, and Reyes held off. Her opinion described this period as "the legal equivalent of Groundhog Day": the plaintiffs asked for relief, the government denied a plan existed, and the court declined to act.
In April, she said she did not want to reach a point where the government told her it was "too late" to stop the project, according to a hearing transcript quoted in her opinion.
That changed in October. On October 10, the Park Service began a new round of tree removal. CNN reported that the agency had told the court it planned to remove 169 trees in that phase. It said it could remove as many as 529 trees in all. The judge's opinion says the agency began clearing trees less than 18 hours after it notified the court, and that by the end of that day it had removed nearly 430 trees.
On October 26, Reyes granted a preliminary injunction. Her written order bars the government from cutting or damaging any tree in East Potomac Park without court approval. It allows an exception for an imminent threat to public safety, which must be reported to the court within 24 hours.
The order also requires the government to give at least 10 business days' written notice before closing the course or making "irreversible" changes to the park. Each notice must name every person who authorized or will carry out the action. It must also say whether the action is tied to the Washington National Plan or any Fazio design.
In her opinion, Reyes found that the Washington National Plan "exists." She pointed to Trump's public statements about it, statements by Interior Secretary Doug Burgum, the soil dumped on the course, and the tree removal. She found that the government's stated reason for the tree work was "pretextual," meaning it was not the real reason. Those are findings at an early stage of the case. They are not a final judgment.
"Rarely, if ever, has the United States Department of Justice urged a federal court not to believe the sitting President," Reyes wrote in that opinion, as quoted by MS NOW.
The appeal and the November 15 date#
The government has appealed the October 26 injunction to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, MS NOW reported. The appeal is pending. The injunction stays in force while the appeal goes forward unless a court says otherwise.
The October 26 order also told the government to explain by October 28 why it should not have to preserve information about the plan and the tree removal. Friday's preservation order, as reported by Bloomberg Law, came after that step.
Two dates now matter most. The first is the deadline for the Justice Department to object to a special master. The second is November 15, the closing date Trump has announced.
The injunction does not ban a closing outright. It requires 10 business days' notice, with detailed information. The Justice Department's October 28 filing told the court about the planned November 15 closing, but it is not yet clear whether the court will treat that filing as the formal notice the order requires.
Separately, the Fazio design is now before the National Capital Planning Commission. That agency's review is a separate step from the lawsuit.
Why the case draws attention#
East Potomac Golf Links has been open to the public since the 1920s, according to CBS News. It sits in East Potomac Park, on the peninsula known as Hains Point.
Bloomberg Law described the case as one of a slew of legal challenges to Trump's projects in the capital. It also listed other changes he has made or tried to make there. They include the demolition of the White House East Wing for a ballroom, a color change to the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool basin, paving over part of the Rose Garden and attempts to rename and close the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts.
Trump has said a new course would bring tournaments and business to the city. In January, he said he wanted a "U.S. Open-caliber course" and that "it's going to bring a lot of business into Washington," according to a video cited in the judge's opinion.
Critics, including the plaintiffs, say the project would make a public course more expensive to play and would change a historic landscape without the required review. The Park Service had estimated the project's preliminary cost at $20 million to $49 million, CNN reported earlier this month.
The judge's inquiry is focused on the conduct of lawyers, not on whether a new course is a good idea. The Justice Department has been involved in other high-profile fights in the courts this month, including over the Big Bend border wall and the Comey prosecutions.
How this story was reported#
This article is based on the judge's October 26 order and 70-page memorandum opinion in DC Preservation League v. Department of Interior, No. 1:26-cv-477 (D.D.C.), and on reporting from CBS News, Bloomberg Law and MS NOW about Friday's hearing. Earlier details about the tree removal come from CNN. Quotes from the hearing are attributed to the outlets that reported them, because an official transcript was not yet available. Where outlets differed, such as on how the special master would be used, this article notes the difference.
567politics does not take sides in this case. Readers can see how we handle sources and disputed claims on our methodology page.
Differing perspectives
Is the tree removal at East Potomac Golf Course part of a plan to rebuild the course?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Stop piecemeal implementation of the plan
Who holds it: DC Preservation League and golfers Dave Roberts and Alex Dickson, plaintiffs
In their Oct. 14 memorandum, plaintiffs wrote that defendants "have been saying one thing and doing another: insisting that there is no plan to destroy East Potomac Golf Course, but all the while implementing that plan piecemeal." They cite Trump's January remark about a "world-class, U.S. Open-caliber course," Interior Secretary Burgum's May posts, and the cutting of hundreds of trees on Oct. 10 with barely 12 hours' notice.
In their words: Plaintiffs' memorandum, Doc. 80-1, D.D.C. No. 1:26-cv-00477 (via CourtListener) ↗
Tree removal with substantial independent utility
Who holds it: Interior Department, National Park Service and other federal defendants
In their Oct. 16 opposition, defendants wrote that plaintiffs lack Article III standing and that "there has been no final agency action on the proposal," which they describe as "a yet-to-be-finalized proposal to redesign and renovate the East Potomac Golf Course." They argue that "the tree removal project has 'substantial independent utility' without regard to whether or when the proposal is finalized and implemented."
In their words: Defendants' opposition, Doc. 84, D.D.C. No. 1:26-cv-00477 (via CourtListener) ↗
Cite this article
567politics News Desk. “Judge opens inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court over Trump's golf course plan.” 567politics. Published 2026-10-30. Updated 2026-11-02. https://www.567politics.com/news/east-potomac-golf-course-judge-reyes-inquiry-doj-october-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Judge opens inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court over Trump's golf course plan |url=https://www.567politics.com/news/east-potomac-golf-course-judge-reyes-inquiry-doj-october-2026 |work=567politics |author=567politics News Desk |date=2026-10-30 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://www.567politics.com/news/east-potomac-golf-course-judge-reyes-inquiry-doj-october-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Judge opens inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court over Trump's golf course plan",
"URL": "https://www.567politics.com/news/east-potomac-golf-course-judge-reyes-inquiry-doj-october-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567politics News Desk"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
10,
30
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://www.567politics.com/embed/news/east-potomac-golf-course-judge-reyes-inquiry-doj-october-2026?theme=auto" title="Judge opens inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court over Trump's golf course plan by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Judge opens inquiry into whether government lawyers misled her court over Trump's golf course plan by <a href="https://www.567politics.com/news/east-potomac-golf-course-judge-reyes-inquiry-doj-october-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://www.567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Order granting preliminary injunction, DC Preservation League v. Department of Interior, No. 1:26-cv-477 (Dkt. 101, Oct. 26, 2026) ↗
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (via Democracy Forward)
Bars tree removal without court approval and requires 10 business days' notice before closure or irreversible changes.
- primary evidence
Memorandum opinion, DC Preservation League v. Department of Interior (Dkt. 103, Oct. 26, 2026) ↗
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (via CourtListener)
Judge Reyes's 70-page opinion; summarizes both sides' arguments and her preliminary findings.
- independent analysis
Judge opens inquiry into whether Trump officials misled court in D.C. golf course case ↗
CBS News
Details the specific questions the inquiry will examine and the five-day window to object to a special master.
- independent analysis
Judge to Probe If DOJ Broke Ethics Rules in Golf Course Case ↗
Bloomberg Law
Hearing account including the preservation order and the executive privilege exchange.
- independent analysis
Fiery golf course hearing ends with a bang: Judge calls for a probe into government lawyers ↗
MS NOW
Includes the Justice Department spokesperson's response and notes the pending appeal.
- other perspective
Crews begin clearing 169 trees at DC golf course Trump plans to convert to championship course ↗
CNN
Carries the Interior Department's statement and the park superintendent's sworn account that the tree work is not part of a redesign.
- other perspective
Tree removal at D.C. golf course not part of Trump's redesign, officials say ↗
The Washington Post
September hearing where Justice Department lawyers said the trees were dead, dying, hazardous or invasive and argued the plaintiffs lack standing.
- independent analysis
Tree removals at East Potomac golf course raise alarms ↗
Axios Washington D.C.
Earlier background with views from a local advocacy group and the Interior Department.
- independent analysis
Trump Appeals Judge's Order After 400 Trees Cut Down at DC Golf Course ↗
Law Commentary
Covers the government's appeal of the Oct. 26 injunction to the D.C. Circuit.
Reviewed 2026-10-30. Sources were opened and checked on Oct. 30, 2026. The court order and opinion are primary evidence. Friday's hearing has no public transcript yet, so hearing details rely on CBS News, Bloomberg Law and MS NOW, which differ slightly on how a special master would be used. The Interior Department's and Justice Department's positions are represented through their statements to CNN, Axios and the Washington Post and through the government arguments summarized in the court's opinion. No left- or right-leaning commentary arguing for either side of the misconduct inquiry was found and verified, so none is labeled that way; this is a dispute over court candor and environmental review rather than a partisan policy debate. Politico and AP coverage exists but could not be opened from our research environment, so it is not listed.