{"version":"1.9","identifier":"0e120b90-0222-4425-b51d-2923d7b8c3d0","language":"en-US","title":"IFS says Healey's Budget leaves a £28 billion gap for next year's Spending Review","layout":{"columns":7,"width":1024,"margin":32,"gutter":20},"componentLayouts":{"text":{"columnStart":0,"columnSpan":7,"maximumContentWidth":720,"margin":{"top":12,"bottom":12}},"photo":{"columnStart":0,"columnSpan":7,"margin":{"top":20,"bottom":20}}},"componentTextStyles":{"default":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":18,"lineHeight":29,"textColor":"#171717"},"headline":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue-Bold","fontSize":36,"lineHeight":42,"conditional":[{"conditions":{"maxViewportWidth":480},"fontSize":28,"lineHeight":34}]},"intro":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":20,"lineHeight":28,"textColor":"#555555"},"caption":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":13,"lineHeight":19,"textColor":"#666666"},"byline":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":13,"lineHeight":20,"textColor":"#666666"},"body":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":18,"lineHeight":29,"paragraphSpacingAfter":14,"linkStyle":{"textColor":"#00704a"}}},"metadata":{"canonicalURL":"https://www.567politics.com/news/uk-budget-healey-obr-ifs-spending-squeeze-october-2026","datePublished":"2026-10-30T19:19:48.206657Z","dateModified":"2026-11-06T20:39:19.897909Z","authors":["567politics News Desk"],"excerpt":"The think tank says avoiding real-terms cuts could take £17 billion more for services in 2030-31, plus £11 billion for defense. Parties split over the remedy.","thumbnailURL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/0e120b90-0222-4425-b51d-2923d7b8c3d0/f0b3b86a6fe97a2f44fd3c226cca4e92.jpg","keywords":["economy"],"generatorName":"Frog News","generatorVersion":"1.0"},"components":[{"role":"title","text":"IFS says Healey's Budget leaves a £28 billion gap for next year's Spending Review","textStyle":"headline","layout":"text"},{"role":"intro","text":"The think tank says avoiding real-terms cuts could take £17 billion more for services in 2030-31, plus £11 billion for defense. Parties split over the remedy.","textStyle":"intro","layout":"text"},{"role":"byline","text":"By 567politics News Desk · Published October 30, 2026","textStyle":"byline","layout":"text"},{"role":"photo","URL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/0e120b90-0222-4425-b51d-2923d7b8c3d0/f0b3b86a6fe97a2f44fd3c226cca4e92.jpg","caption":"Chancellor John Healey (right) with US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent at the G20 finance ministers' meeting in Asheville, North Carolina, on August 30, 2026. · Kirsty O'Connor / HM Treasury via Wikimedia Commons, Open Government Licence v3.0","accessibilityCaption":"Chancellor John Healey (right) with US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent at the G20 finance ministers' meeting in Asheville, North Carolina, on August 30, 2026.","layout":"photo"},{"role":"caption","text":"Chancellor John Healey (right) with US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent at the G20 finance ministers' meeting in Asheville, North Carolina, on August 30, 2026. · Kirsty O'Connor / HM Treasury via Wikimedia Commons, Open Government Licence v3.0","textStyle":"caption","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"A day after Chancellor [John Healey](https://www.567politics.com/politicians/john-healey) delivered his first Budget, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said his plans leave a difficult choice for next year's Spending Review. At its post-Budget briefing on October 29, the independent think tank said that avoiding real-terms cuts for unprotected government departments could require a £17 billion top-up to spending plans for 2030-31. That figure comes before an estimated £11 billion needed to raise defense spending to 3% of GDP, a commitment the Budget left for the Spending Review to settle.\n\nThe warning sharpened a debate that began when the Budget was published on October 28. The government says it has helped households through an energy shock while staying within its fiscal rules. Conservatives and Reform UK say it borrows and taxes too much and cuts too little. The Greens and trade unions say it does too little to raise revenue from wealth and protect public services. This article sets out what the official forecasts show, what independent analysts said in the two days after the Budget, and how each party responded.\n\n**UK borrowing forecast**\n\nOBR October 2026 forecast. Selected fiscal years, not actual outturns; no annual path inferred between them. Nominal pounds; ratios to GDP differ.","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"htmltable","html":"<table><tr><th>Fiscal year</th><th>Billion pounds</th></tr><tr><td>2026–27</td><td>£133bn</td></tr><tr><td>2030–31</td><td>£67bn</td></tr></table>","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"Source: [October 2026 Economic and Fiscal Outlook](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/october-2026-economic-and-fiscal-outlook/economic-and-fiscal-outlook-october-2026)\n\n## What the IFS said on October 29\n\nAccording to [the Guardian's report on the briefing](https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/29/john-healey-budget-brutal-spending-review-next-year-ifs), IFS director Helen Miller said Healey had left overall departmental spending plans for the rest of the parliament broadly unchanged in cash terms. Because inflation is now forecast to be higher than in the spring, the same cash buys less, which in effect pencils in cuts in the run-up to the next general election.\n\n\"It effectively implies that some public services will see real-terms cuts in next year's spending review,\" Miller said. She added that low headroom and \"a spending review that looks pretty brutal for some departments\" could bring \"another season of damaging speculation about tax rises.\"\n\nMiller also questioned whether the cuts would happen. \"My concern is not that it would be impossible to deliver the implied cuts to other services – that could be done,\" she said. She added that she doubted this government would be willing to do it. The Guardian noted that Labour has promised there will be no return to austerity.\n\nThe IFS did not fault every choice. Miller called it a \"reasonable choice\" for the chancellor to accept a modest fall in headroom, given weak forecasts for growth and living standards. The [IFS event page](https://ifs.org.uk/events/autumn-budget-2026-ifs-analysis) lists the October 29 webinar, at which Miller and IFS researchers presented their overnight analysis of the forecasts and the main tax and spending decisions.\n\nIn its [initial response on Budget day](https://ifs.org.uk/articles/autumn-budget-2026-initial-response), the IFS said the Budget contained a \"raft of fiddly measures but very little that will move the dial on growth.\" It called the \"very tight plans for public service spending\" the Budget's \"Achilles' heel\" and said \"next year's Spending Review will be a crunch point.\"\n\n## What the official forecast shows\n\nThe Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) published its [October 2026 Economic and Fiscal Outlook](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/october-2026-economic-and-fiscal-outlook/economic-and-fiscal-outlook-october-2026) alongside the Budget. Its main figures are:","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"htmltable","html":"<table><tr><th>Measure</th><th>OBR forecast</th></tr><tr><td>GDP growth</td><td>About 1¼% in 2026 and 1% in 2027</td></tr><tr><td>CPI inflation</td><td>Peaking at about 3¾% in early 2027; about 3½% across 2027</td></tr><tr><td>Headroom against the main fiscal rule</td><td>£15 billion in 2029-30, down £7 billion from the 2025 Budget</td></tr><tr><td>Chance of meeting that rule</td><td>56%</td></tr><tr><td>Borrowing</td><td>4.2% of GDP (£133 billion) in 2026-27, falling to 1.8% (£67 billion) in 2030-31</td></tr><tr><td>Debt</td><td>Peaking around 97% of GDP in 2028-29</td></tr><tr><td>Debt interest</td><td>£109 billion (3.5% of GDP) in 2025-26, rising to £160 billion in 2031-32</td></tr></table>","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"The OBR said Budget policy measures add £8 billion to borrowing in 2026-27 and £4 billion in 2027-28. It said the tax take would pass its previous record of 37.2% of GDP in 2027-28. It also published a scenario in which higher energy prices would add £17 billion to borrowing in 2027-28.\n\nOn living standards, the OBR said real household disposable income per person would \"fall slightly in the near term\" and, in 2030-31, would be only around 2% above pre-pandemic levels. [The Guardian's Budget-day report](https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/oct/28/obr-slashes-uk-growth-forecast-for-2027-despite-healey-budget-measures) quoted OBR committee member David Miles describing a \"pretty grim picture\" for households, with disposable income per person forecast to fall 0.6% next year.\n\nThe Guardian compares the new figure with the £23.6 billion buffer left by Healey's predecessor, [Rachel Reeves](https://www.567politics.com/politicians/rachel-reeves), in the spring. The OBR's own comparison is with the 2025 Budget, when the fiscal rules were last formally assessed, which is why it puts the fall at £7 billion. The smaller headroom reflects higher government borrowing costs since the war in the Middle East pushed up energy prices and inflation.\n\n## What the Budget contained\n\n[BBC coverage of the Budget](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqpvgxz3y49go) listed the main measures:\n\n* A one-off £100 payment toward energy bills for households in council tax bands A to D in England, which the Guardian said would reach about 20 million households at a cost of £2.6 billion.\n* Gas standing charges scrapped, and the fuel duty cut extended to July.\n* The bank surcharge doubled from 3% to 6% from January 2027 to April 2028.\n* Tax rates on savings and property income raised to 24% for basic-rate taxpayers.\n* The threshold for small business rates relief raised from £12,000 to £18,000.\n* A planned cut to the cash ISA allowance scrapped.\n* Mayors allowed to keep 20% of business rates raised in their areas.\n* The minimum wage raised by 3.9%.\n* The plan to reach 3% of GDP on defense deferred to the Spending Review.\n\n## Independent assessments of living standards\n\nThe [Resolution Foundation](https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/budget-balancing-act-leaves-families-braced-for-tough-winter-and-four-year-living-standards-downturn/), a think tank focused on living standards, called the energy support \"badly targeted.\" It said about four in five properties in England qualify for the £100 payment, while around one in eight households in the bottom half of the income distribution live in higher-band homes and would miss out.\n\nThe foundation forecast that energy bills will average £2,210 across 2027, up £600 on the 2026 average, and said support of up to £116 would offset less than a fifth of that rise. It estimated that unprotected departments such as Justice, Transport and Work and Pensions face real cuts of 6.7%, or £12 billion in total, by the end of the forecast. It also said it would take until April 2029 for household incomes per person to recover from the fall of the past two years.\n\nThe foundation praised some measures. It called the higher tax rates on savings and property income \"sensible\" and said they narrow a gap that taxes employees more heavily than people who draw income from other sources. Chief executive Ruth Curtice said it was \"questionable whether the tight public spending plans required to meet his fiscal rules will survive reality.\"\n\nPressure on unprotected departments has already drawn attention in Parliament. Before the Budget, the cross-party Commons Justice Committee asked ministers how justice reforms would be funded across legal aid, prisons and courts, as 567politics reported in its [story on the committee's pre-Budget questions](https://www.567politics.com/news/uk-justice-committee-budget-funding-october-27-2026).\n\n## The government's defense\n\nPrime Minister [Andy Burnham](https://www.567politics.com/politicians/andy-burnham) defended the package on October 29. \"It's pretty bold to help 20 million households with energy costs through the council tax cut this winter,\" he told broadcasters, according to [the Independent](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/andy-burnham-john-healey-institute-for-fiscal-studies-robert-jenrick-kemi-badenoch-b3075293.html). He also cited the decision to take 70,000 businesses out of business rates altogether.\n\nBurnham also conceded the limits. \"We're doing what we can to support people in difficult times,\" he said, adding that the government does not have much room to maneuver. \"The fiscal rules are met, so we've done all of this within a very prudent and stable approach.\" In his Budget speech, Healey said the aim was \"to steer us through the global economic storms today,\" the Independent reported.\n\nSupporters of the government's approach point to three things. The fiscal rules are still met. Part of the relief is paid for by higher taxes on banks and landlords, according to the Guardian. And the IFS judged a modest fall in headroom a \"reasonable choice\" given weak forecasts for growth and living standards.\n\n## Criticism from the right\n\nConservative leader [Kemi Badenoch](https://www.567politics.com/politicians/kemi-badenoch) said the government was \"overspent, overborrowed, overtaxed and drowning in an out-of-control welfare system,\" the BBC reported. She also said Healey \"should have set out a plan for 3% today\" on defense. According to [City AM](https://www.cityam.com/is-that-it-badenoch-lays-into-healey-budget-speech/), she asked in the Commons: \"Is that it?\" and mocked a measure she described as \"4p off gherkins.\" City AM reported that the Conservatives propose £70 billion of spending cuts, about half from welfare. The Independent reported that she called the Budget \"not good enough, not strong enough, not bold enough.\"\n\nReform UK leader [Nigel Farage](https://www.567politics.com/politicians/nigel-farage) said \"Britain is broke\" in the party's [published reaction](https://www.reformparty.uk/news/budget-2026-nigel-farage-robert-jenrick-reaction). He told the BBC the Budget was full of \"little giveaways\" but \"doesn't overall do very much,\" and offered nothing \"of any value\" on defense. The party says it would cut spending by £40 billion in its first financial year in government, rising to £80 billion over five years. Robert Jenrick, whom the party describes as its shadow chancellor, called the Budget a \"nothing burger.\"\n\nThe core of the right's argument is that the government should cut spending, particularly on welfare, rather than raise taxes. Critics on the right also argue that a tax take at a record share of GDP holds back growth. The IFS warning about deferred decisions gives these critics a further point: if the Spending Review does not deliver the implied restraint, borrowing or taxes may have to rise again.\n\n## Criticism from the left\n\nOn the left, critics argue the Budget should have raised more from wealth and protected public services. Green Party leader [Zack Polanski](https://www.567politics.com/politicians/zack-polanski) said it was a Budget \"that betrays the future for young people and the planet they inherit,\" according to the BBC, adding that the chancellor \"didn't mention climate once but praised bankers repeatedly.\" The Green Party's [official response](https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/10/28/green-party-reaction-to-autumn-2026-budget/), from the party's Treasury spokesperson Ellie Chowns, called it a \"business-as-usual Budget\" that chose to \"tinker round the edges\" rather than tax \"extreme wealth and profits.\" She also criticized the chancellor for assuming in his plans that the Rosebank oil field will be approved.\n\nUnite general secretary Sharon Graham described the measures as \"baby steps,\" the BBC reported. The Trades Union Congress took a more supportive line: in a [blog post on October 29](https://www.tuc.org.uk/blogs/john-healeys-budget-provides-relief-more-will-be-needed-years-ahead), general secretary Paul Nowak welcomed the higher bank surcharge but said more support would be needed in the years ahead.\n\nThe core of the left's argument is that real-terms cuts to unprotected departments would amount to the return to austerity that Labour promised to avoid. These critics say the gap should be closed with new taxes on wealth rather than spending restraint. The IFS figure of £17 billion needed to avoid such cuts in 2030-31 is the number these critics are most likely to cite.\n\nLiberal Democrat leader Ed Davey focused on trade. He said that until the government has \"the courage\" to fix the UK's trading relationship with the European Union, any Budget will be \"tinkering around the edges,\" according to the BBC.\n\n## Where the two critiques meet\n\nThe right and left disagree on the remedy but share a diagnosis: both say the Budget postponed the hardest choices. The IFS and Resolution Foundation reached a similar conclusion from a nonpartisan starting point. The disagreement is about what should happen when the Spending Review arrives. One option is cuts to unprotected departments, which the right broadly supports and the left opposes. Another is higher taxes, which the left supports and the right opposes. A third is more borrowing, which the OBR's narrow headroom and the IFS's warnings make costly.\n\nFor background on the parties and the next general election, see 567politics' [United Kingdom election guide](https://www.567politics.com/elections/united-kingdom).\n\n## What to watch\n\n* **The Spending Review in 2027:** 567politics did not find a published date in the sources reviewed. The review will set department budgets and decide how to fund the 3% defense commitment.\n* **Gilt yields:** the Resolution Foundation noted that borrowing costs kept rising after the OBR closed its forecast, which it estimated could imply about £2 billion of extra debt interest costs.\n* **Energy prices:** the OBR's high-price scenario would add £17 billion to borrowing in 2027-28.\n* **Delivery of the £100 payment:** how and when households in bands A to D receive it this winter.\n\n## How this article was reported\n\nThis article draws on the OBR's published forecast, the IFS's initial response and event materials, the Resolution Foundation's Budget-day analysis, party statements and reporting by the Guardian, the BBC, the Independent and City AM. Opinion polls on the Budget are not cited because full poll details were not available in the sources reviewed.","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"}]}