Skip to content
567politics.

Poland

Kaczyński floats EU exit talks as a pressure tactic; Tusk says 2027 vote will decide Poland's place in EU

The PiS leader says he wants EU reform, not Polexit. The governing coalition says the remarks reveal where the opposition is heading.

By 567politics News DeskPublished Updated 10 min read

Jarosław Kaczyński, leader of Law and Justice (PiS), in Warsaw in March 2024.
Jarosław Kaczyński, leader of Law and Justice (PiS), in Warsaw in March 2024. · Photo: Klub Lewicy via Wikimedia Commons, public domain ↗

Jarosław Kaczyński leads Law and Justice (PiS), Poland's main opposition party. On Wednesday, October 28, he said that opening talks on leaving the European Union could be a last-resort way to force the bloc to reform. Prime Minister Donald Tusk answered the next day that the parliamentary election due in autumn 2027 would be "a prelude to a referendum" on whether Poland stays in the EU.

Kaczyński says he is not proposing that Poland leave, and his deputies have repeated that PiS has no plans for "Polexit." The governing coalition says the remarks show where the opposition is heading. The row has drawn in nearly every party, including the right-wing Confederation, which says Kaczyński has adopted its call to abolish the European Commission.

This article sets out what Kaczyński said, how each side has responded, and what polling shows about Polish attitudes toward EU membership.

Polish support for EU membershipCBOS survey described in the article: n=938 adults, random PESEL sample, mixed interview modes. Fielded January 8–20, 2026; margin of error not stated. Opinion, not a referendum result.

Source: "Poles on European integration"

Show the numbers
ResponseShare
Support82%
Oppose14%
Undecided4%
Share this chartPost

What Kaczyński said in Krynica#

Kaczyński spoke for nearly an hour at a session titled "Europe of States and Nations: The Future of the European Union" at the Krynica Forum 2026, a political and economic conference in southern Poland. The pro-PiS news site wPolityce published a transcript of the passage that caused the dispute. Quotations from Polish-language sources are 567politics translations. Where PAP or 300polityka published English versions, those are used.

According to Radio Kraków, he called the European Commission "very harmful" and said, "It should not exist." He proposed that the European Council, where national governments sit, take over its role. He called the European Parliament a "parody of a parliament" and said its members should be replaced by delegates from national parliaments. Radio Kraków reported that he expects a chance to push these changes if governments change in France, Spain or Germany.

He then described ways to get there. In the transcript, he says that states with more than 35% of the EU's population could form a blocking minority in the Council and stop most decisions. He called this "a very powerful means of pressure." If that and other methods failed, he proposed that the states seeking change sign a new treaty that would take effect only after a delay. Alongside that, he pointed to the EU treaty provisions on how a member state can leave.

"It all begins with negotiations, and simply starting these negotiations," Kaczyński said, in the English translation by PAP, Poland's state news agency. "It is a hard method, a risky one, but things are really so bad... that it is worth employing such a method if others fail." He added that the approach would need determination and agreement among like-minded states whose views, especially on "Eastern policy," differ.

The government's response#

Tusk responded on X on Thursday morning, writing that Kaczyński "has just announced that Poland should begin negotiations on the conditions of leaving the European Union," according to PAP. He said he did not intend to lose the fight "even if not everyone plays on my side."

Later on Thursday he posted a video statement. In it, as reported by 300polityka, he said: "the elections in a year, those in 2027, will be a prelude to a referendum on whether Poland remains in the European Union or leaves it." He compared the debate to Brexit, saying he had seen "how British politicians said exactly the same things that Kaczyński, Nawrocki, Bosak, or Mentzen are saying today." He argued that talks presented as reform could become talks on the terms of exit. "That's how a catastrophe begins," he said.

Tusk's post on X read:

"Nie pozwolę, by prawica wyprowadziła nas z Unii Europejskiej. O to dziś toczy się gra." ("I will not allow the right to take us out of the European Union. That is what is at stake today.") — Donald Tusk (@donaldtusk), October 29, 2026

According to Rzeczpospolita, citing PAP, Tusk said Poland's economy had tripled in nominal terms since joining the EU in 2004, and that the country had received more than €160 billion from the EU budget after its own contributions. Finance Minister Andrzej Domański wrote that GDP per person is 42% higher because of membership and that at least 5 million jobs are tied to the single market. These are government figures; 567politics has not independently checked them.

Ministers from the other coalition parties joined in, PAP reported. Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski said leaving would mean "a customs border with Germany, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, and Lithuania, passport controls at airports, and an end to EU subsidies for farmers and investments." In a separate post cited by Euronews, he noted that a draft of a new EU treaty Kaczyński had promised earlier never reached the foreign ministry.

Defense Minister Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz leads the agrarian Polish People's Party. He linked the remarks to the opposition's votes against SAFE, an EU program of defense loans of up to €150 billion, which President Karol Nawrocki vetoed in March. He said the EU should be reformed "where improvement is needed, not threatened with an exit," and called on PiS and the Confederation to say before the election whether they want Polexit.

From the left, Sejm Speaker Włodzimierz Czarzasty of the New Left said Kaczyński was getting the public used to the idea of Poland leaving the EU, PAP reported, and added: "They are moving East. We are staying." In a video on Friday morning, reported by Wirtualna Polska, he asked Kaczyński, "Have you lost your common sense and reason?" He pointed to how Poland has changed over 30 years and to free travel under the Schengen agreement. Special services coordinator Tomasz Siemoniak said "even Kremlin dreamers would not have predicted a significant Polish politician speaking directly against Poland's interests." Government spokesman Adam Szłapka tied the comments to Grzegorz Braun, an MEP who leads the Confederation of the Polish Crown, a smaller far-right, Euroskeptic party. Szłapka said Kaczyński "is implementing Braun's agenda."

The PiS response#

Kaczyński replied on X the same day. "Tusk, as usual, is lying," he wrote, according to PAP and Euronews. "The European Union is needed, but it requires thorough reform." He blamed the EU's problems on former German Chancellor Angela Merkel and on Tusk's time as president of the European Council. He said PiS wants an EU focused on lower energy prices, stronger security, "responsible migration policy" and less bureaucracy. "We will restore the European Union to its citizens," he wrote.

PiS vice-chair Przemysław Czarnek said the party has no plans for Polexit and that Kaczyński's remarks were about reforming the EU, PAP reported. The wPolityce article argued that government politicians "either did not understand" what Kaczyński said or "deliberately twisted" it, and noted that the exit passage was a short part of a long speech.

Some inside PiS saw the episode differently. Newsweek Polska quoted an unnamed person close to Kaczyński as saying the remark "was a mistake," and another PiS source describing the X post as "damage control." An associate of Kaczyński told the magazine that Polexit "will not be our card in the campaign." These sources were not named, and 567politics could not verify their accounts.

Divisions on the right#

Former Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, who left PiS and now leads his own group, Rozwój Plus, distanced himself. "Rozwój Plus is a firm supporter of Poland's presence in the European Union, although the European Union of course needs repairing," he said, according to Euronews. He said he wants deep changes to EU migration, climate and fiscal policy, but "we are not the formation that calls for Polexit."

The Confederation, a right-wing alliance, took a different line. In statements on its website, MEP Anna Bryłka said Kaczyński had "supported our proposal to abolish the European Commission." She said Confederation leaders had raised it this year, including at a June event in the Sejm with Jordan Bardella, president of France's National Rally. Deputy Speaker Krzysztof Bosak said PiS "in opposition declares something completely different" from what it did in government, and accused it of supporting the Lisbon Treaty without a referendum. "In a year, Poland needs real change, not a return of mistaken policy masked by strong words," Bosak wrote.

Kaczyński's interest in allies abroad is part of the background. Newsweek Polska noted that Kaczyński sees a "window of opportunity" if Marine Le Pen's party wins power in France, alongside Italy's prime minister, Giorgia Meloni. The National Rally's own position on EU institutions is set out in 567politics' France issues guide.

The arguments on each side#

PiS and its supporters argue that the EU has drifted toward central control from Brussels, that the Commission and the Court of Justice hold too much power, and that only strong pressure, including the threat of blocking decisions, will produce reform. They say critics have taken one passage out of context and that Kaczyński has said he does not want Polexit.

The governing coalition and its supporters argue that threats to leave are not a reform strategy and that, as Tusk said of Brexit, such talks can end in a departure. They also say membership is central to Poland's security while Russia's war on Ukraine continues. Tusk said Poland's departure "would be one of the greatest gifts" to Moscow, Rzeczpospolita reported.

The Confederation sits between these positions. It wants deeper changes to the EU than PiS has proposed in the past, while saying PiS has not been consistent.

What polls show#

Recent public polling on EU membership is limited. The most recent detailed survey 567politics found is from the Public Opinion Research Center (CBOS), carried out for its regular "Current problems and events" survey series and published in its report "Poles on European integration". It was carried out from January 8 to 20, 2026, about nine months before this dispute, and should be read with that in mind.

  • Sample: 938 adults drawn at random from Poland's PESEL population register.
  • Method: mixed mode, with 55.5% of interviews face-to-face (CAPI), 26.4% by phone (CATI) and 18.0% online (CAWI).
  • Question: "Do you personally support Poland's membership in the European Union, or are you opposed to it?"
  • Result: 82% support, 14% oppose, 4% undecided. Support peaked at 92% in June 2022.
  • Margin of error: not stated in the report.

In a second question asking which vision of Poland's future in the EU respondents preferred, 5% chose leaving the EU and 23% chose limiting integration and strengthening national states. Another 32% chose keeping the current level of integration and 26% chose deeper integration.

CBOS also broke down support by party. Among PiS voters, 70% supported membership and 26% opposed it. Among supporters of Confederation Liberty and Independence, the alliance's main grouping, 64% supported it and 34% opposed it. CBOS notes that some party subgroups in the sample are small, so these figures carry more uncertainty than the national totals.

What to watch#

  • November 3: President Nawrocki's National Security Bureau meeting, where, PAP reported, there has been a dispute over whether Braun's party should be invited.
  • New polling: whether surveys taken after the Krynica speech show any change in support for membership.
  • Autumn 2027: the parliamentary election, for which no date has yet been set.

For comparison with the British debate Tusk cited, see 567politics' United Kingdom issues guide, including former prime minister David Cameron's 2016 referendum.

How this article was reported#

This article draws on reporting by PAP, Euronews, Rzeczpospolita, Radio Kraków, 300polityka, Newsweek Polska and Wirtualna Polska; the transcript published by wPolityce; statements published by the Confederation; and the CBOS survey report. Polish party and campaign finances are reported to the National Electoral Commission (PKW). This article concerns policy statements rather than any politician's finances, so no funding records are discussed. 567politics does not currently have profiles of the Polish politicians named here. 567politics follows a published methodology for sourcing and attribution.

Differing perspectives

Could opening EU withdrawal talks as a pressure tactic put Poland's EU membership at risk?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • Pressure for reform, not exit

    Who holds it: Law and Justice leader Jarosław Kaczyński and vice-chair Przemysław Czarnek

    Kaczyński told the Krynica Forum that starting exit negotiations is "a hard method, a risky one," but worth using "if others fail." On X he wrote that "the European Union is needed, but it requires thorough reform." Czarnek said the party has no plans for Polexit and that the remarks were about reforming the EU.

    In their words: Polish Press Agency (PAP), Oct. 29, 2026 ↗

  • Reform talks could become exit talks

    Who holds it: Prime Minister Donald Tusk

    Tusk said the 2027 elections "will be a prelude to a referendum on whether Poland remains in the European Union or leaves it." He said talks presented as reform can become "talks about the terms of Poland's exit from the European Union." He compared Kaczyński's remarks to Brexit and said: "That's how a catastrophe begins."

    In their words: 300polityka, Oct. 29, 2026 ↗

Cite this article

567politics News Desk. “Kaczyński floats EU exit talks as a pressure tactic; Tusk says 2027 vote will decide Poland's place in EU.” 567politics. Published 2026-10-30. Updated 2026-11-06. https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Kaczyński floats EU exit talks as a pressure tactic; Tusk says 2027 vote will decide Poland's place in EU |url=https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026 |work=567politics |author=567politics News Desk |date=2026-10-30 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Kaczyński floats EU exit talks as a pressure tactic; Tusk says 2027 vote will decide Poland's place in EU",
  "URL": "https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567politics News Desk"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        10,
        30
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://www.567politics.com/embed/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026?theme=auto" title="Kaczyński floats EU exit talks as a pressure tactic; Tusk says 2027 vote will decide Poland's place in EU by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Kaczyński floats EU exit talks as a pressure tactic; Tusk says 2027 vote will decide Poland's place in EU by <a href="https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://www.567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-10-30. Sources opened and checked by the Lane C writer on Oct 30, 2026. The discover_politics_sources tool returned only unrelated results (supplements, Microsoft pages), so none were used. No left-leaning outlet with an argued piece was found in time; the left case is represented through Wirtualna Polska's report of New Left leader Włodzimierz Czarzasty's statements, and coalition positions through PAP and Polish Radio. The CBOS poll predates the dispute (January 2026) and has no stated margin of error.

All 567politics news →