{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-constitutional-tribunal-swieczkowski-suspended-nawrocki-october-2026","title":"Poland's Constitutional Tribunal president suspended by a new judge; Nawrocki calls it a forcible takeover","description":"Riot police surrounded the court in Warsaw as President Nawrocki flew back from Senegal. Lawyers disagree on whether the suspension has a legal basis.","author":"567 Politics staff","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-31T11:11:14.099874Z","date_modified":"2026-11-06T20:45:21.481652Z","body_markdown":"Poland's long dispute over its Constitutional Tribunal turned into a physical standoff on Friday night, October 30. A judge elected by the current parliament announced that she had suspended the court's president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and his deputy, Bartłomiej Sochański. Riot police surrounded the building in Warsaw, protesters gathered, and President Karol Nawrocki turned his plane back from a trip to Senegal and went to the court in the early hours of Saturday.\n\nThe government of Prime Minister Donald Tusk says it is restoring a court that was captured by the previous Law and Justice (PiS) government. Nawrocki, PiS and the right-wing Confederation say the government has taken over a constitutional body by force. Constitutional lawyers, including some who have long criticized PiS, disagree about whether the suspension has any legal basis. On Saturday afternoon Nawrocki began a series of emergency meetings with parliamentary party leaders.\n\nQuotations from Polish-language sources are 567politics translations unless an English version is linked.\n\n\n```chart\ntype: bar\ntitle: Who is right in Poland’s Tribunal dispute?\nnote: IBRiS for Rzeczpospolita, October 16–17, 2026, n=1,068. Other responses omitted; method and margin not given in cited summary. Predates the suspension and is not a legal finding.\nsuffix: %\nsource: [IBRiS for Rzeczpospolita](https://wiadomosci.gazeta.pl/polityka/7,198012,33103838,spor-o-trybunal-konstytucyjny-polacy-odpowiedzieli-w-sondazu.html)\n---\nResponse | Share\nNawrocki | 32\nTusk | 27.8\nNeither | 32.7\n```\n\n\n## What happened on Friday night\n\nAccording to [Notes from Poland](https://notesfrompoland.com/2026/10/30/chaos-at-polands-constitutional-court-as-government-backed-judges-seek-to-oust-chief-justice/), a brief statement appeared on the Tribunal's website on Friday evening announcing a \"break in the activities\" of Święczkowski and Sochański. The court's spokeswoman, Weronika Ścibor, spoke to the broadcaster Kanał Zero. She said seven people elected as judges this year had been escorted in by the State Protection Service, which reports to the interior minister. They came through a gate from the prime minister's office. [Euronews](https://www.euronews.com/2026/10/31/poland-political-crisis-constitutional-court-in-chaos-as-nawrocki-accuses-government-of-st) reported that Święczkowski and Sochański were reportedly denied entry.\n\nJudge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska then told the public broadcaster TVP that she had issued the suspension order. The Tribunal's X account said \"an unlawful takeover\" of the court's website had occurred and that Święczkowski \"remains chief justice.\" It said Korwin-Piotrowska \"is not a [Constitutional Tribunal] judge\" and that \"all persons participating in these actions are committing the crime of a coup d'état,\" as quoted by Notes from Poland.\n\nNotes from Poland reported that police kept Święczkowski out after his supporters cut through the fence with a power tool. [The Guardian](https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/31/riot-police-deployed-to-polands-constitutional-court-after-judge-suspended) reported that hundreds of protesters, including opposition MPs, gathered, and that police detained three people after some protesters breached the fence and others threw objects at officers. [Anadolu Agency](https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/explainer-police-deployed-after-head-of-top-court-suspended-president-cuts-trip-short-whats-happening-in-poland/4106989) reported that police denied claims that officers had stormed the building and said they had not entered it.\n\nNawrocki announced on X that he was cutting short his flight to Senegal. \"At such a moment, the President must be in Poland,\" he wrote, according to Anadolu. After meeting Zbigniew Kapiński, the First President of the Supreme Court, he went to the Tribunal and arrived shortly before 1 a.m. on Saturday. The Guardian described video showing him \"tussling with security and other judges to force his entry into the building,\" and reported that he was still inside at 4 a.m. local time. [Onet](https://wiadomosci.onet.pl/kraj/karol-nawrocki-spotka-sie-z-liderami-partii-politycznych-znamy-godzine/n1x079x) reported that one such video was published by Judge Maciej Berek, one of the new appointees.\n\nBefore 5 a.m., Nawrocki's chief of staff, Paweł Szefernaker, read a statement outside the court. \"Tonight, there has been a breach of the constitutional order of the Republic of Poland and a forcible takeover of a constitutional organ of the state,\" it said, in Euronews's translation. It called for \"the forces of coercion sent there by the government to leave the Tribunal's grounds.\"\n\n## The legal basis claimed for the suspension\n\nThe legal portal [Prawo.pl](https://www.prawo.pl/prawnicy-sady/spor-o-trybunal-konstytucyjny-anna-korwin-piotrowska-zawiesza-w-czynnosciach-swieczkowskiego,1556200.html) published the text of Korwin-Piotrowska's order. She claims to lead the court as the judge with the longest combined legal service, counted from the start of her judicial training on September 1, 1995. Under the law on the Tribunal's organization, that judge runs the court when the presidency is vacant. She ordered an immediate one-month break in Święczkowski's duties. She cited Article 130 of the law on the common courts. She applied it to the Tribunal through rules on Supreme Court judges and the law on the status of Tribunal judges.\n\nThe order gives three groups of reasons. First, it says Święczkowski blocked four judges elected on March 13, 2026, from the Tribunal's General Assembly, which left the court unable to adopt its draft budget for 2027 and put its funding at risk. Second, it says he did not allow five Sejm-elected judges to hear cases and did not comply with an interim measure issued by the European Court of Human Rights on May 5, 2026. Third, it accuses him of letting politicians into the building, including during Berek's oath on October 14, and of making political public statements.\n\nJustice Minister and Prosecutor General Waldemar Żurek also filed five motions to lift the two men's immunity, four concerning Święczkowski, Prawo.pl reported. Under Article 196 of the constitution, a Tribunal judge cannot be prosecuted without the Tribunal's consent. Prawo.pl notes that consent requires a resolution of the General Assembly with at least two-thirds of the 15 judges present, or 10 judges.\n\n## How the court reached this point\n\nThe dispute dates to 2015. The Guardian summarizes it this way: the outgoing centrist and incoming right-wing majorities moved in quick succession to fill the bench with their own appointees. Anadolu reports that the European Court of Human Rights and the EU's Court of Justice later ruled that the PiS majority had improperly elected three judges. Those seats had already been filled by the previous parliament. The European courts found the Tribunal was no longer an \"independent and impartial tribunal.\" Tusk's government has relied on those rulings to stop publishing the Tribunal's judgments since taking office in late 2023.\n\nIn 2026 the governing majority began filling vacancies. Notes from Poland reports that parliament has chosen eight judges this year, enough in theory for a majority of the 15-seat bench. Polish law requires new judges to take their oath \"before the president.\" According to [Gazeta.pl, citing PAP](https://wiadomosci.gazeta.pl/polityka/7,198012,33103838,spor-o-trybunal-konstytucyjny-polacy-odpowiedzieli-w-sondazu.html), Nawrocki invited only three of the eight — Magdalena Bentkowska, Dariusz Szostek and Sławomir Patyra — to be sworn in. The other five, Krystian Markiewicz, Marcin Dziurda, Korwin-Piotrowska, Maciej Taborowski and Berek, took their oaths in the Sejm and submitted them to the president's office. The president's office says that does not entitle them to take office; the judges say their oath was addressed to the head of state even though he was absent. Święczkowski has not admitted them to hear cases.\n\nOn October 13 the Council of Europe's Venice Commission, an advisory body on constitutional law, published an [opinion on the president's powers](https://www.coe.int/en/web/venice-commission/-/cdl-ad-2026-031-e). [PAP reported](https://www.pap.pl/en/news/venice-commission-calls-nawrocki-swear-remaining-top-court-judges) its main finding: \"The President should administer without delay the oath of the judges elected by the Sejm, without claiming any power to review the election procedure.\" The opinion added that judges may take office without him if he \"unlawfully refuses to administer the oath.\" Presidential spokesman Rafał Leśkiewicz replied that the opinion was not binding. He said the constitution and statutes, not Venice Commission opinions, define the president's powers.\n\nA separate row the same week, over [Kaczyński's comments about EU exit talks](/news/poland-kaczynski-eu-withdrawal-talks-tusk-referendum-october-2026), also points toward the autumn 2027 parliamentary election.\n\n## The government's case\n\nTusk defended the operation on social media. \"Restoring the rule of law is our duty,\" he wrote, as quoted by Notes from Poland and the Guardian. \"After years of PiS-led lawlessness, this is a difficult process, sometimes painful, and it requires decisive action. There is no other way.\" Earlier this month, according to the Guardian, he pledged that \"the court will begin its work in accordance with the constitution, whether people like it or not.\"\n\nForeign Minister Radosław Sikorski, speaking at the [G20 foreign ministers' meeting in Atlanta](/news/politics-today-october-30-2026-comey-g20-china-russia), gave the most detailed version of the government's argument. [Anadolu reported](https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/polish-foreign-minister-defends-police-action-at-constitutional-tribunal-amid-political-dispute/4106987) that he said the court had been \"politicized under the previous government.\" He said most judges elected by the new parliament could not work because the court's president had not convened its assembly. As a result, he said, the Tribunal could not issue judgments, interpret laws or approve its budget. \"So, action had to be taken to enable the tribunal to function again,\" he said.\n\nŻurek, according to Euronews, said talks had been held with Sochański but produced no compromise. He said the president's conduct \"alarmed me enormously,\" that footage showed Nawrocki \"forcing his way in and attacking the judges,\" and that he hoped prosecutors would act.\n\nThe government's case rests on three points: European courts found defects in how the Tribunal was composed; the Venice Commission says the president cannot block Sejm-elected judges; and a court that cannot decide cases or pass a budget is not performing its constitutional role.\n\n## The president's and the opposition's case\n\nNawrocki's statement said neither he nor Kapiński recognized the actions of those who, in his view, were unlawfully claiming authority in the Tribunal, according to Euronews. In a clip cited by the Guardian, he said the government's appointees \"were not judges of the constitutional court.\" Kapiński told Kanał Zero he was \"appalled\" and called it \"undoubtedly a coup d'état,\" Notes from Poland reported.\n\nKaczyński, speaking outside the court, said \"as of today, Poland has become a police state, and from there it's a straight path to authoritarianism, and then to totalitarianism,\" according to Notes from Poland. Former Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, now leading the Rozwój Plus group, wrote that the government \"must be stopped and must answer for the coup it carried out last night,\" Onet reported.\n\nThe strongest form of this side's argument is procedural. Article 195 of the constitution says Tribunal judges are subject only to the constitution. Article 130, the provision cited in the order, lets a court president or the justice minister suspend a judge of the ordinary courts, [as Prawo.pl explains](https://www.prawo.pl/prawnicy-sady/spor-o-trybunal-konstytucyjny-anna-korwin-piotrowska-zawiesza-w-czynnosciach-swieczkowskiego,1556200.html). Nawrocki and Kapiński's position is that a judge whose own oath the president does not recognize cannot remove the court's president. The president's office also stresses that the Venice Commission's opinion is advisory.\n\n\"Coup d'état\" and \"police state\" are characterizations by participants, not findings of any court, and no Polish or European court has yet ruled on the October 30 suspension.\n\n## Lawyers who usually disagree with PiS are split\n\nMarcin Matczak is a law professor and longtime critic of PiS's judicial changes. He wrote on X that he considered Święczkowski \"the worst person to serve as the president of the [Tribunal].\" But he called the legal basis for the suspension \"nonexistent for a million reasons,\" according to Notes from Poland. Prawo.pl quotes his fuller argument. Discipline of Tribunal judges is regulated in detail, so a catch-all clause cannot apply. The Article 130 power belongs to the justice minister for ordinary courts. And the minister has no supervisory power over the Tribunal. Prawo.pl adds that the Tribunal itself ruled in 2009 that Article 130 is an emergency procedure with two substantive conditions.\n\nOthers take the opposite view. Marek Chmaj, a constitutional lawyer, pointed Prawo.pl in mid-October to doubts about the vote that produced Święczkowski's nomination. Judges that European courts regard as improperly appointed took part in it. On that basis, he said, \"it can hypothetically be said that such a vacancy exists.\" If the presidency is vacant, the longest-serving judge would lead the court and call the General Assembly. Prawo.pl also notes that Korwin-Piotrowska's seniority claim rests on her career since 1995, not on time at the Tribunal.\n\n## Saturday's talks\n\nSzefernaker said Nawrocki would begin meetings with parliamentary leaders at 1 p.m. Warsaw time on Saturday, Onet reported. Morawiecki said he would attend at 4 p.m.; Confederation's Sławomir Mentzen said he and Krzysztof Bosak would attend at 4:45 p.m. Szymon Hołownia, leader of the coalition party Polska 2050, wrote that his parliamentary club would take part. \"Poland needs peace today, not war,\" he wrote. The right-leaning site [Niezależna.pl](https://niezalezna.pl/polska/seria-spotkan-w-palacu-prezydenckim-koalicjanci-tuska-chowaja-glowy-w-piasek-ale-nie-wszyscy/582952) reported that he was the only coalition leader to accept publicly by late Saturday morning. 567politics did not find a confirmed decision from Civic Coalition, the Polish People's Party or the Left.\n\n## Reactions abroad\n\nThe Guardian reported that Britain's [Nigel Farage](/politicians/nigel-farage) and [Liz Truss](/politicians/liz-truss) and the Netherlands' Geert Wilders condemned the suspension. US Ambassador Tom Rose wrote on X that the events were \"very serious.\" \"Both sides offer sharply different accounts of what happened and why,\" he wrote, according to the Guardian. \"The last thing Poland needs is a confrontation that spirals into something far worse.\" Anadolu reported that Poland's ambassador to China, Jakub Kumoch, resigned, writing that he could \"no longer serve.\" No EU institution statement on the Friday events was found in the sources reviewed for this article.\n\n## What polling shows\n\nThe most recent representative poll found for this article predates Friday's events. [IBRiS for Rzeczpospolita](https://wiadomosci.gazeta.pl/polityka/7,198012,33103838,spor-o-trybunal-konstytucyjny-polacy-odpowiedzieli-w-sondazu.html), conducted October 16–17 among a representative sample of 1,068 people, asked who is right in the Tribunal dispute: President Nawrocki or Prime Minister Tusk. Of respondents, 32.0% chose Nawrocki, 27.8% chose Tusk and 32.7% said neither. Among supporters of the governing coalition, 73% backed Tusk; among opposition supporters, 60% backed Nawrocki. The published summary did not state the interview method or margin of error; by 567politics' calculation, sampling error for a simple random sample of that size would be roughly ±3 percentage points.\n\n567politics did not find a representative poll measuring reaction to the October 30 suspension itself, and social media reactions from the night are not a measure of public opinion.\n\n## What to watch\n\n- **The immunity motions.** Lifting immunity needs a General Assembly resolution with 10 judges present. Whether the new judges can form that quorum, and whether any result would be recognized by the president and opposition, is unresolved.\n- **The 2027 budget.** The suspension order says the court could not adopt its spending plan. Watch whether a General Assembly convened by Korwin-Piotrowska submits one and whether the finance ministry accepts it.\n- **Competing claims.** Two groups now claim to speak for the Tribunal, one through its website and one through its X account.\n\nOur [methodology page](/methodology) explains how 567politics labels contested claims and polls.","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/poland-constitutional-tribunal-swieczkowski-suspended-nawrocki-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}