{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/ninth-circuit-diversity-visa-lottery-stay-october-2026","title":"Appeals court lets 2027 diversity visa lottery stay closed, citing law firm's standing","description":"A Ninth Circuit panel paused an order to open registration by Nov. 1. It said a law firm likely cannot sue, but did not endorse the delay.","author":"567politics News Desk","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-30T19:26:36.88949Z","date_modified":"2026-11-06T20:44:39.97124Z","body_markdown":"A federal appeals court has let the State Department keep the 2027 diversity visa lottery closed while it appeals. A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit granted the government's emergency request on Thursday, Oct. 29. The ruling puts on hold a lower court order that told the department to open registration by Sunday, Nov. 1.\n\nThe panel did not rule that the department acted lawfully. \"We do not endorse the Department's failure to open the lottery registration period,\" the judges wrote in their [published order](https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca9/26-6943/26-6943-2026-10-29.html). Instead, they found that the only plaintiff, an immigration law firm, was likely the wrong party to bring the case.\n\nThe ruling matters for a program Congress wrote into law in 1990. Each year it offers green cards to people from countries that send few immigrants to the United States. For fiscal year 2027, which began Oct. 1, no one has been able to enter the lottery at all.\n\n\n```chart\ntype: bar\ntitle: Origins of diversity immigrants, 1995–2017\nnote: Congressional Research Service historical summary. Selected regions; other origins omitted. Shares of diversity immigrants in that period, not all immigrants or a forecast for 2027.\nsuffix: %\nsource: [Congressional Research Service historical report](https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R45973.html)\n---\nRegion | Approximate share\nAfrica | 40\nEurope | 31\nAsia | 25\n```\n\n\n## What the appeals court decided\n\nThe case is *Red Eagle Law, L.C. v. Rubio*, No. 26-6943. The panel was made up of Circuit Judges M. Margaret McKeown, N. Randy Smith and Holly A. Thomas. McKeown was appointed by President Bill Clinton. Smith was appointed by President George W. Bush. Thomas was appointed by President Joe Biden. The order was unsigned, which courts call per curiam. Smith also wrote a separate concurrence.\n\nTo win a stay, the government had to make a strong showing that it is likely to win the appeal. The panel said it had done so. The reason was a legal test called the \"zone of interests.\" Under the Administrative Procedure Act, a person suing an agency must show that their interest is at least arguably one the law was meant to protect.\n\nThe panel said a law firm's interest in fees does not pass that test here. The program's purpose \"is to encourage immigration from countries with low immigration rates,\" the judges wrote. The law \"was enacted to encourage immigration, not generate revenue for law firms.\"\n\nRed Eagle had pointed to a 2018 Ninth Circuit ruling that let legal aid groups challenge asylum rules. The panel said that case was different. The asylum law expressly mentions access to pro bono lawyers. The diversity visa law has no similar language about legal help, the panel said.\n\nSmith's concurrence went further. He wrote that Red Eagle also lacks standing under Article III of the Constitution. In his view, the firm's harm is too speculative. A foreign national would have to enter the lottery, win, apply, pass a consular interview and then choose to hire this firm. \"Any injury (given these facts) cannot be concrete or particularized,\" he wrote.\n\nSmith also warned about the wider effect of the lower court's theory. If lawyers could sue over lost future clients, he wrote, \"we would be opening the floodgates.\" He noted that his opinion \"should not be read to absolve\" the State Department of what he called its \"admission that it failed to follow the law.\"\n\nThe stay is not a final ruling. The court's clerk will set a schedule for full briefing on the appeal.\n\n## What the trial judge had ordered\n\nU.S. District Judge Jinsook Ohta of the Southern District of California granted the injunction at a hearing on Oct. 14. Ohta was appointed by Biden. Her [written opinion](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-casd-3_26-cv-04738/pdf/USCOURTS-casd-3_26-cv-04738-0.pdf), filed Oct. 19, explains her reasoning. Under her order, the department had to announce a registration period by Oct. 29. It had to open registration by Nov. 1 and notify winners by Dec. 3.\n\nOhta found that the department had given no reason for skipping the lottery. In past years, registration usually opened in early October. On Nov. 5, 2025, the department posted a notice. It said it was \"implementing certain changes\" to the entry process. It promised to announce a start date \"as soon as practicable.\" Ohta wrote that the department had still done nothing almost a year later.\n\n\"The State Department does not even attempt to argue in its briefing that it has articulated a reasoned basis,\" Ohta wrote. She ruled that its inaction was likely arbitrary and capricious under federal law.\n\nOhta also found that Red Eagle had standing. The firm said it has represented several hundred diversity visa winners since it was founded in 2023. It said that work made up 29 percent of its gross revenue as of September 2026. Ohta compared the firm to businesses that courts have allowed to sue over rules that shrink their market.\n\nThe government made two other arguments. It said it was too late to run the lottery, since the timing set by law had passed. Ohta disagreed. She said Congress set a hard limit only at the end of the fiscal year, not at the start. The government also said the order acted like a nationwide injunction, which the Supreme Court limited in its 2025 ruling in *Trump v. CASA*. Ohta said that ruling does not narrow relief under the Administrative Procedure Act. She added that there was no narrower way to fix the firm's harm.\n\nThe appeals panel did not reach either of those questions. It ruled only on whether the firm could bring the case.\n\n## How the program works\n\nCongress created the Diversity Visa Program in the Immigration Act of 1990. A [Congressional Research Service report](https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R45973.html) says the goal was to foster \"new seed\" immigration from a wider range of countries. Most green cards go to people with family ties or job offers in the United States. The lottery is one of the few paths that requires neither.\n\nThe law sets aside up to 55,000 visas a year. In practice, about 50,000 have been available. The research service's 2019 report explains why. Since 2000, a 1997 law has cut the ceiling by 5,000 a year. Those visas offset green cards for certain asylum seekers from El Salvador, Guatemala and former communist countries in Europe. Natives of countries that sent 50,000 or more immigrants in the prior five years cannot enter.\n\nWinners are chosen at random from millions of entries. The State Department picks about 100,000 people, more than the number of visas, because many do not complete the process. Winners must still apply, pass background checks and attend an interview. They must receive their visa before the fiscal year ends on Sept. 30. Unused slots do not carry over to the next year.\n\nThe research service found that from 1995 through 2017, about 40 percent of diversity immigrants came from Africa. About 31 percent came from Europe and 25 percent from Asia.\n\n## How the pause began\n\nThe 2027 lottery was delayed in November 2025. A broader pause followed in December. That month, a gunman killed two students and wounded nine others at Brown University. He also killed a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The suspect was Claudio Neves Valente, a Portuguese national who was later found dead. [PBS NewsHour, citing the Associated Press](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-suspends-green-card-lottery-program-that-let-brown-university-mit-shootings-suspect-into-u-s), reported that he received a diversity visa in 2017.\n\nOn Dec. 18, 2025, Kristi Noem, who led the Department of Homeland Security at the time, said she had ordered a pause at President [Donald Trump](/politicians/donald-trump)'s direction. \"This heinous individual should never have been allowed in our country,\" she said, according to the AP. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services put pending green card applications from lottery winners on hold the next day. The State Department told consular officers to refuse diversity visas the day after that.\n\nThose pauses applied to the 2026 lottery winners. Courts later blocked them. On Aug. 25, 2026, U.S. District Judge Richard J. Leon in Washington [declared the pauses unlawful](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.290420/gov.uscourts.dcd.290420.52.0.pdf) for the named plaintiffs in three cases. On Aug. 28, a federal court in Northern California went further in *Medani v. Trump*. It temporarily set aside the pauses for a class of 2026 winners. [USCIS said](https://www.uscis.gov/newsroom/alerts/court-order-on-diversity-immigrant-visa-program-hold-policy) it \"strongly disagrees\" with that order but would follow it. The State Department announced that its pause was no longer in effect, according to the [American Immigration Lawyers Association](https://www.aila.org/library/dos-announces-compliance-with-court-order-halting-diversity-visa-issuance-pause).\n\nThose rulings did not address the 2027 lottery. In the Red Eagle case, the government itself said the December pause was \"distinct\" from the timing of the 2027 registration period, according to Ohta's opinion. Ohta wrote that the government explained the December pause in its filings. But she said it gave no reason at all for the 2027 delay.\n\n## The case for ending or pausing the lottery\n\nThe program has long drawn criticism, mostly from Republicans. The research service summarizes the main arguments. Critics say the lottery is open to fraud and could let in people who pose a security risk. They point to how hard it is to run background checks in some eligible countries. Some argue that choosing immigrants by nationality is unfair. Others say the visas would be better used for skilled workers or to cut backlogs in other categories.\n\nTrump has opposed the lottery for years. After the Brown shootings, Noem noted that he had also sought to end it after a 2017 truck attack in New York City. The man convicted in that attack had also entered through the lottery, as [The Times of India reported](https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/us/visa-applicants-go-through-indian-origin-congresswoman-weighs-in-on-trump-suspending-us-green-card-lottery/articleshow/126084380.cms) in its account of her remarks. USCIS has said its hold was meant to make sure applicants \"do not pose a threat to national security or public safety.\"\n\nSeveral Republican bills would repeal the program. Rep. [Mike Collins](/politicians/mike-collins) of Georgia introduced the [SAFE for America Act](https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/1241/text) (H.R. 1241) in February 2025. Rep. [Keith Self](/politicians/keith-self) of Texas introduced a [one-section repeal bill](https://www.congress.gov/119/bills/hr10896/BILLS-119hr10896ih.htm) (H.R. 10896) on Oct. 22, 2026. Sen. [Tommy Tuberville](/politicians/tommy-tuberville) of Alabama included repeal in a [broad immigration bill](https://www.congress.gov/119/bills/s4546/BILLS-119s4546is.htm) (S. 4546) in May. All three remain in committee.\n\n## The case for keeping the lottery\n\nSupporters, mostly Democrats and immigrant advocates, make a different case. The research service summarizes their view. They say the lottery adds variety to a system that favors a small number of countries. They say fraud has dropped since the State Department added safeguards. They also note that lottery winners face the same criminal and security checks as other green card applicants. Some say the program supports equal opportunity and U.S. foreign policy goals.\n\nRep. [Pramila Jayapal](/politicians/pramila-jayapal) of Washington criticized the December pause. \"Visa applicants go through some of the most rigorous vetting our country has,\" she wrote on X, as quoted by The Times of India. She said Trump was \"exploiting this horrific tragedy\" to \"shut down more legal pathways.\"\n\nRep. [Yvette Clarke](/politicians/yvette-clarke) of New York introduced the [Diversity Visa Protection and Modernization Act](https://www.congress.gov/119/bills/hr9457/BILLS-119hr9457ih.htm) (H.R. 9457) in June with 28 cosponsors, all Democrats. The bill's findings say program-wide or open-ended suspensions go beyond the authority Congress gave the executive branch. It also remains in committee.\n\nBoth courts also agreed on one point. Neither found a lawful reason for skipping the 2027 lottery. Ohta found none. The appeals panel said it did not endorse the delay.\n\n## How to weigh the claims\n\nSome facts are not in dispute. The law requires the State Department to run the program each year. No 2027 registration has opened. The department has not published a reason for that in its notices or, according to Ohta, in its court briefs. The appeals ruling turned on who may sue, not on whether the delay was lawful.\n\nOther claims are harder to test. The security argument rests on specific cases, such as the 2017 attack and the Brown suspect. Those cases are real. But the research service's summary shows that critics and supporters disagree about how the program's risk compares with other visa paths. Neither the court record nor the State Department's notices in this case offer data on that question. Likewise, Jayapal's view that the pause was meant to cut legal immigration is her reading of the administration's goals, not a finding by any court.\n\nThe legal fight is also less about immigration than about the rules for suing. Ohta cited the Supreme Court's statement that the zone-of-interests test is \"not meant to be especially demanding.\" The appeals panel applied it more narrowly to this statute. Smith added that, in his view, complaints about how the government runs a program belong with Congress or the president unless a directly harmed party sues. Both relied on earlier rulings. The full appeal will decide which reading holds.\n\n## Funding records\n\n567 Politics checked its campaign finance records for the officials named in policy roles here. For Collins, Self and Clarke, the Federal Election Commission identity has been verified, but no funding snapshot has been published yet. For Secretary of State [Marco Rubio](/politicians/marco-rubio), the named defendant, no FEC identity has been verified in our records. This article makes no claim about any of their donors. Missing data does not mean zero donations.\n\n## The calendar and the next lawsuit\n\nTime is the main pressure on all sides. Lottery winners must receive visas by Sept. 30, 2027. Each week without a lottery leaves less time to pick winners, run checks and hold interviews. If the year ends with no lottery, those visas cannot be used later.\n\nRed Eagle plans to keep going. \"Red Eagle will be moving forward quickly with other litigation to challenge the State Department's failure to carry out the DV program,\" owner Curtis Morrison [told Newsweek](https://www.newsweek.com/green-card-update-judge-freezes-reopening-of-diversity-visa-lottery-12639675). Newsweek reported that the firm is looking for a foreign national living in the United States on a temporary visa to serve as a plaintiff. Newsweek said it had asked the State Department for comment.\n\nImmigration policy is tracked in our [United States issue guide](/issues/united-states#immigration). Our [methodology page](/methodology) explains how we source claims about court cases.","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/ninth-circuit-diversity-visa-lottery-stay-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}