{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/medicaid-medically-frail-ruling-stearns-october-2026","title":"Judge rejects CMS 'medically frail' test for Medicaid work rule but upholds two verification limits","description":"A federal judge sided with 25 states and D.C. on who counts as medically frail under the 2025 budget law. The work rule itself still starts Jan. 1, 2027.","author":"567politics News Desk","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-30T19:13:37.175944Z","date_modified":"2026-11-06T20:40:43.117576Z","body_markdown":"A federal judge in Boston ruled on Thursday, Oct. 29, that the Trump administration went too far in defining who is \"medically frail\" under Medicaid's new work rule. The rule had told states that people with serious conditions must also prove those conditions \"significantly impair\" their ability to meet the work standard. The judge said the law does not allow that extra test. He left the work requirement itself in place. He also upheld two other federal limits on how states check frailty.\n\nThe rule matters for millions of low-income adults. Most states must start the work requirement by Jan. 1, 2027. The ruling changes who can skip it.\n\nU.S. District Judge Richard Stearns sided in part with 25 states and the District of Columbia. They sued in June. The defendants are the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz. [The Associated Press reported](https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/10/30/judge-blocks-trump-administrations-medicaid-rule-forcing-sick-recipients-to-prove-frailty) that CMS declined to comment. [Reuters, as published by NBC News](https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-care/judge-blocks-medically-frail-definition-medicaid-work-requirement-rule-rcna606397), said the agency did not respond right away. By Friday afternoon, 567 Politics had found no public statement from HHS or the Justice Department on an appeal.\n\n\n```chart\ntype: bar\ntitle: CMS projected Medicaid spending reduction\nnote: CMS 10-year cost analysis of the work rule, as described in this article. Forecast reductions, not observed savings. The ruling changes part of the rule; no separate effect of that part is established.\nprefix: $\nsuffix: bn\nsource: [CMS fact sheet](https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/medicaid-community-engagement-requirement-certain-individuals-interim-final-rule-comment-period-cms), [interim final rule in the Federal Register on June 3, 2026](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/06/03/2026-11094/medicaid-program-community-engagement-requirement-for-certain-individuals)\n---\nGovernment level | Billion US dollars\nFederal | 350.3\nState | 41.6\n```\n\n\n## What the court decided\n\nThe 2025 budget law, Public Law 119-21, set the work rule. It covers most adults aged 19 to 64 who joined Medicaid through the Affordable Care Act's expansion. Each month they must show 80 hours of work, community service, a work program or half-time school. Earning at least 80 times the federal minimum wage also counts. That is $580 a month in 2026, according to a [CMS fact sheet](https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/medicaid-community-engagement-requirement-certain-individuals-interim-final-rule-comment-period-cms).\n\nThe law exempts several groups. They include pregnant people, parents of children 13 and under, American Indians and Alaska Natives, and veterans with a total disability rating. People who are medically frail are exempt too.\n\nCongress listed who must count as medically frail. The list has five groups:\n\n- people who are blind or disabled under the Social Security Act;\n- people with a substance use disorder;\n- people with a disabling mental disorder;\n- people with a disability that significantly limits one or more activities of daily living;\n- people with a serious or complex medical condition.\n\nThe [states' complaint](https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/court-filings/massachusetts-et-al-v-mehmet-oz-m.d-et-al-complaint-2026_0.pdf) notes that a CMS bulletin from December 2025 repeated this list with no added test.\n\nThen CMS published its [interim final rule in the Federal Register on June 3, 2026](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/06/03/2026-11094/medicaid-program-community-engagement-requirement-for-certain-individuals). The rule added a second step. A person had to fit one of the five groups. Their condition also had to \"significantly impair\" their \"ability to comply with the community engagement requirement.\" Under that reading, a serious diagnosis alone was not enough.\n\nJudge Stearns held that the second step was contrary to the law. [Healthcare Finance News reported](https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/court-rejects-cms-definition-medically-frail-medicaid) that the court found the agency could not remove anyone from the five groups Congress named.\n\nReuters quoted the judge on the harm: \"Because enforcement of an unlawful definition of 'medically frail' may lead to the disenrollment of otherwise eligible vulnerable individuals relying on Medicaid coverage for continuity of care, the States (and public) face potential for great hardship in the absence of an injunction.\"\n\nThe AP quoted another passage from the 16-page ruling: \"The states have met their burden of showing irreparable harm for which monetary damages would provide inadequate compensation — they face the burden of costly and intensive alterations to their eligibility verification systems.\"\n\nTwo state attorneys general described the remedy. They are [Rob Bonta](/politicians/rob-bonta) of California and [Kris Mayes](/politicians/kris-mayes) of Arizona. Their offices said the court struck the added language, issued a permanent injunction and gave the states a six-month pause on enforcing frailty decisions. The pause is meant to give states time to fix their systems. The [California release](https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-secures-major-victory-blocking-implementation-unlawful) and the [Arizona release](https://www.azag.gov/press-release/attorney-general-mayes-secures-major-victory-blocking-implementation-unlawful) use the same wording. 567 Politics could not get the opinion from a public docket on Friday. So the exact scope of the order is described here as the states and news reports have put it.\n\n## What the government won\n\nThe ruling was not a full loss for the administration. Judge Stearns upheld two rules the states also fought.\n\nThe first bars states from using diagnoses or claims data more than 12 months old to prove frailty. The second lets a person self-attest to frailty only once per stretch of enrollment. Healthcare Finance News said the judge found the states' objections fell \"well short\" of the legal standard for striking a rule as arbitrary.\n\nThe AP quoted the court: \"the government provided a non-frivolous rationale for adopting each provision and explained why it did not find the States' concerns of disenrollment compelling.\"\n\nThe states had also argued that the rule broke the Constitution's Spending Clause. That clause requires clear notice of the terms attached to federal money. News reports on the ruling did not describe a decision on that claim. This article does not describe one either.\n\nThe case is No. 1:26-cv-12962, filed June 29. The complaint's caption lists Massachusetts, California, New Jersey, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, the District of Columbia, Hawaii, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, New Mexico, New York, Nevada, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin. Kentucky joined through Gov. Andy Beshear and Pennsylvania through Gov. Josh Shapiro. Reuters said the attorneys general of California, Massachusetts and New Jersey led the case. It described the plaintiffs as Democratic-led states.\n\n## How many people the rule affects\n\nCMS's own numbers show the stakes. In the rule's cost analysis, the agency projected that the work requirement would cut Medicaid enrollment by 2.3 million people in fiscal 2027. That first year is only partial. In later years, CMS projected a drop of 3.1 million to 3.3 million. It estimated that federal Medicaid spending would fall by $350.3 billion over 10 years. State spending would fall by $41.6 billion.\n\nCMS said those figures are \"subject to uncertainty.\" They blend four scenarios. They also do not estimate how many people who lose Medicaid find other coverage.\n\nCMS also assumed that about 7 percent of people who work, study or qualify for an exception would still lose coverage for paperwork reasons. One example is missing a request to verify their status. The agency based that on renewal data showing an average procedural loss rate of about 12 percent. CMS did not say how much of its projected drop came from the frailty test the court has now struck.\n\nThe Congressional Budget Office has looked at the law as a whole. In August 2025, CBO estimated it would raise the number of uninsured people by 10 million in 2034. The Medicaid work rule alone would add 5.3 million before interactions with other parts of the law. That is according to a [summary by Georgetown University's Center for Children and Families](https://ccf.georgetown.edu/2025/08/14/new-cbo-health-coverage-estimates-of-budget-reconciliation-law/). CBO and CMS use different baselines and years. Their numbers should not be added together.\n\nThe states' complaint cites CMS data showing almost 75 million people in Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program. About 20 million of them are in the expansion group, across 41 states.\n\nA KFF study looked at Medicaid adults aged 19 to 64 who do not get Social Security disability benefits. Using 2023 Census survey data, it found that [64 percent were working](https://www.kff.org/medicaid/issue-brief/understanding-the-intersection-of-medicaid-and-work-an-update/). Another group was not working because of caregiving, illness, disability or school. Together, the two groups made up 92 percent. KFF also found that adults with a disability were less likely to work, 37 percent versus 68 percent. KFF notes that survey totals differ from state records.\n\n## The case for the states' reading\n\nThe states argue that Congress wrote the five groups itself. In their view, CMS cannot shrink them.\n\nNew York Attorney General [Letitia James](/politicians/letitia-james) put it this way in a [statement](https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2026/attorney-general-james-protects-medicaid-coverage-vulnerable-new-yorkers): people \"living with cancer, a disability, a serious mental health condition, or addiction should never have to prove they are sick enough to keep their health care.\"\n\nTheir policy case rests on paperwork. The states say past work rules caused eligible people to lose coverage. KFF points to Arkansas. It was the only state to enforce a work rule under the first Trump administration's waivers. About 18,000 people lost coverage there before courts struck down the waiver. CMS's own 7 percent paperwork assumption fits that concern. But CMS presents it as a model input, not a finding about any state.\n\nMorgan Henderson studies Medicaid at The Hilltop Institute at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County. He told the AP the ruling would likely protect \"those individuals who would have lost coverage because they're sick but they're not quite sick enough.\" Dev Sangvai, North Carolina's health secretary under Gov. [Josh Stein](/politicians/josh-stein), said the ruling lets the state focus on \"delivering reliable health care to our state's most vulnerable residents.\"\n\nThe states also say a list-based test is easier to run. States already hold data such as claims records. A test of each person's ability to work needs one-on-one reviews. The states say those are costly to build before January.\n\n## The case for the administration's reading\n\nCMS argues that \"medically frail\" means more than having a diagnosis. The phrase, in its view, implies reduced capacity.\n\n\"Reading the statute to require automatic classification as medically frail or otherwise having special medical needs based solely on diagnosis or condition would risk sweeping in individuals whose conditions do not significantly impair their functional capacity,\" the agency wrote in the rule. It gave examples. A person whose HIV is well controlled may be able to work. So may someone healing from a fracture or pneumonia. CMS said work \"could potentially help them escape isolation and dependency, build confidence, achieve self-sufficiency and prosperity, and improve health.\"\n\nThe Paragon Health Institute made a similar case. Paragon is a market-oriented health policy group led by Brian Blase, a former Trump White House adviser. In a [July 31 public comment](https://paragoninstitute.org/medicaid/public-comment-medicaid-program-community-engagement-requirement-for-certain-individuals/), it urged CMS to defend the rule in court.\n\nParagon pointed to the law's words \"as defined by the Secretary.\" If Congress's list were the full definition, it argued, those words would mean nothing. Courts generally try to give every word in a law some effect. Paragon also wrote that \"two individuals with the same medical condition may have vastly different functional capacities.\" It said a list-based test would excuse many people who could meet \"the modest monthly requirement.\"\n\nParagon's wider point is about state incentives. The federal government pays 90 percent of costs for expansion adults. That, Paragon argued, gives states a reason to read exemptions broadly. It cited a New York Times report in which a New York City health official called the frailty exemption \"kind of squishy.\" The official also discussed tools to let doctors certify frailty quickly.\n\nParagon also cited its own estimate that about 9.2 million people were wrongly enrolled in Medicaid expansion in 2024. That figure comes from the group's own forthcoming research. The CMS rule did not use it, and 567 Politics has not verified it.\n\nWhen CMS issued the rule, Oz said it \"helps Americans build skills and independence through work, education, job training, or community service,\" according to the complaint.\n\n## Where each argument holds up\n\nThe two sides largely agree on two facts. Some people with listed conditions can work. And some eligible people lose coverage over paperwork. They differ on which mistake the law accepts. The administration's reading risks dropping some eligible people to avoid excusing people who could comply. The states' reading accepts the opposite risk.\n\nEach side has also used claims that go beyond its evidence. California's release refers to the administration's \"cruel attempts to rip away healthcare.\" That is a claim about motive, and the ruling does not address motive.\n\nOn the other side, the complaint quotes Oz telling reporters that able-bodied enrollees spend on average \"6.1 hours watching television or just hanging around.\" Applied to the frailty dispute, that is a hasty generalization. An average for a whole group says little about whether a person with a disabling mental disorder can work 80 hours a month. Neither framing settles the legal question, which turned on the text of the law.\n\nThe court's answer was narrower than either side's policy case. Judge Stearns did not rule that work requirements are unlawful. He did not require states to accept self-attestation without limits. He ruled that the agency could not remove people from groups Congress listed.\n\n## Appeal options and the January deadline\n\nStates must still start the work rule by Jan. 1, 2027. Some began earlier. Paragon's comment says Nebraska and Montana started months ahead of the deadline, and Arkansas began a soft rollout in July.\n\nThe federal government can appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit and ask for a stay. It is not yet clear whether the ruling covers only the 26 plaintiffs or all states. The states' releases say the court struck the language from the rule. That kind of remedy usually affects a rule for everyone. But the opinion was not public for review.\n\nPublic health coverage is one of the issues on 567 Politics' [United States issue guide](/issues/united-states#healthcare). President [Donald Trump](/politicians/donald-trump) signed the budget law in July 2025. 567 Politics has no verified Federal Election Commission funding snapshot on file for him, and this article reports no campaign-funding link to the rule. Kennedy, a named defendant, has a [567 Politics profile](/politicians/robert-f-kennedy-jr). Our [methodology page](/methodology) explains how we source legal and policy claims.\n\nThree questions remain open. HHS has not said whether it will appeal. CMS has not said how it will revise its guidance for the 43 states and the District of Columbia that, according to CMS, must run the program. And no one has estimated how many people will stay covered under the narrower definition. CMS's model did not isolate that number, and neither the states nor the court has published one.","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/medicaid-medically-frail-ruling-stearns-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}