{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/india-bloc-cec-impeachment-sir-electoral-rolls-october-2026","title":"India's opposition delays its 'public impeachment' of the election chief as Modi and Shah hit back","description":"The INDIA bloc wants Gyanesh Kumar out over the voter-roll review. The Election Commission says its decisions were unanimous; Shah offers a special session.","author":"567politics News Desk","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-30T19:28:16.000468Z","date_modified":"2026-11-06T20:40:48.359717Z","body_markdown":"India's opposition alliance has delayed a symbolic \"public impeachment\" of the country's top election official by one day. The INDIA bloc had planned to stage the event on October 30 against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Rain left the lawns muddy in New Delhi, and the event moved to the afternoon of Saturday, October 31, [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/cec-row-india-bloc-sir-protest-delhi-gyanesh-kumar-october-30-2026-live-updates/article71644149.ece).\n\nThe bloc still plans a large rally at Delhi's Ramlila Maidan on Sunday, November 1. Its demand is Kumar's resignation. The fight is over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter rolls, a national review of who is entitled to vote. The opposition says the review has wrongly removed millions of voters. The Election Commission of India (ECI) says its decisions were lawful and were made by the full three-member panel.\n\nOn October 30, the government side answered. Prime Minister [Narendra Modi](/politicians/narendra-modi) said \"some people\" wanted to \"create chaos\" so that he could be defamed. Home Minister [Amit Shah](/politicians/amit-shah) dared the opposition to debate the issue in a special session of Parliament.\n\n\n```chart\ntype: bar\ntitle: Karnataka’s electoral-roll count before and after SIR\nnote: Figures attributed to The Hindu in this article. Net roll change, not proof that every deletion was wrongful or that the process determined an election result.\nsource: [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/cec-row-india-bloc-sir-protest-delhi-gyanesh-kumar-october-30-2026-live-updates/article71644149.ece)\n---\nStage | Listed voters\nBefore SIR | 55432314\nFinal roll reported October 27, 2026 | 45500011\n```\n\n\n## What the SIR is and why it matters\n\nThe SIR began in Bihar in June 2025. It then spread to other states. The ECI's stated aim is a clean roll, in which every eligible voter is listed and every ineligible name is removed. Voters are \"mapped\" to older rolls, often through a parent or grandparent. A mismatch is flagged as a \"logical discrepancy.\"\n\nThe scale is large. [The Indian Express reported](https://indianexpress.com/article/express-exclusive/election-commission-sir-14-objections-gyanesh-kumar-sukhbir-singh-sandhu-vivek-joshi-10889737/) that the SIR has struck more than 130 million names off draft rolls in 30 states and union territories. Draft deletions are not the same as final removals, since some voters are later restored.\n\nState figures show the effect. Karnataka's final roll lists 45,500,011 voters, down from 55,432,314 before the SIR began, The Hindu reported on October 27. That is a net drop of nearly 10 million. In Delhi, about 3.3 million cases were first flagged as unmapped or as logical discrepancies, the paper reported.\n\nWest Bengal saw the sharpest fight. In February 2026, the Supreme Court moved the last stage there out of the ECI's hands, the Express reported. Judicial officers reviewed about 6 million voters flagged for discrepancies, and about 2.7 million were then deleted. The Express also reported that SIR deletions exceeded the winning margin in 49 of the state's 294 seats. Those seats split closely between the BJP (26) and the Trinamool Congress (21), and the paper said there was no evidence the SIR decided the result.\n\n## The dissent inside the commission\n\nThe current row grew from an Express investigation first published on September 23. It reported that the two other election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, had objected in writing at least 14 times over 10 months. They said some decisions were taken without their knowledge.\n\nOne dispute is over Form 6, the form new voters fill out. In July, the online form began asking whether the applicant or a parent or grandparent appeared on the roll of the last SIR. Joshi had warned on file in May that the form could not be changed that way without the government amending the rules, the Express reported. In August, Sandhu wrote that the change was unauthorized and illegal and must be removed at once, according to the paper.\n\nOther notes questioned who controls the voter-roll software. Joshi warned of a gradual centralizing of the voter database and proposed an audit, the Express reported. Sandhu also asked who had authorized appeals filed in the ECI's name in West Bengal against voters that judicial officers had restored to the rolls.\n\nThe law matters here. Under the 2023 law on the appointment of election commissioners, the panel's business \"shall, as far as possible, be transacted unanimously,\" the Express noted. When members differ, the majority decides.\n\n## The commission's response\n\nThe ECI rejects the charge that Kumar acted alone. In a [September 23 statement](https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=2313884&lang=1&reg=3), it said written notes and objections are a normal part of how a multi-member body works. \"Differing views and observations are a normal part of deliberation in any institution,\" the statement said. It added that all its decisions over the past year, including the SIR, \"are an outcome of the unanimous decisions of the full Commission.\"\n\nThe statement also defended its software. It said its digital platforms, such as ECINet, \"operate under strict data security protocols to prevent unauthorized tampering.\" But the Express noted that the statement did not say who approved the Form 6 change.\n\nThe ECI took the same line in the Supreme Court. In an affidavit filed on October 26, it said the SIR orders of June 2025, October 2025 and May 2026 were each unanimous, [The Economic Times reported](https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/eci-rejects-unilateral-action-charge-against-cec-gyanesh-kumar-tells-supreme-court-all-three-sir-orders-were-unanimous/articleshow/135214598.cms). It said notes and queries made as a file moves are not decisions of the commission. Kumar, Sandhu and Joshi all approved the affidavit, the paper reported.\n\nThe affidavit also said Form 6 itself has not been amended and that only the central government can amend it. The SIR declaration is a separate document, the ECI said. It accepted that the online display could be read as an amendment and said the two would be split from October 21. The ECI also said a newspaper report is not evidence in law. And it argued that a plea to restrain the CEC cannot proceed, since a CEC can be removed only in the way a Supreme Court judge is removed.\n\n## The court case\n\nSeveral petitions are before the Supreme Court. One, filed by Rakesh Kumar Singh, seeks Kumar's suspension and prosecution, according to The Economic Times. Separately, [Rahul Gandhi](/politicians/rahul-gandhi) and other INDIA bloc leaders have challenged the SIR itself. They seek official records, an independent audit of deletions, booth-level lists of deleted voters and protection against removal without notice or a hearing, the paper reported.\n\nOn October 27, the court deferred the hearing and gave the petitioners 10 days to respond to the ECI's affidavit, The Hindu reported.\n\n## The opposition's case\n\nThe bloc says the rolls are being purged and wants Kumar out. Gandhi is the leader of the opposition in the Lok Sabha. \"There is huge anger and emotional pain because large numbers are being disenfranchised,\" he said on October 30, according to The Hindu. He also said Shah was \"trying his best\" to stop people from other states from joining the Delhi rally.\n\nThe bloc said the event would avoid imagery that could be seen as mocking Parliament, The Hindu reported. Gandhi said the November 1 event would be a single protest open to all. Trinamool Congress MP Derek O'Brien said the alliance was united. \"We are all in this together,\" he said. The Samajwadi Party's Dharmendra Yadav said the postponed event would take place around 3 p.m. on October 31.\n\nThe opposition also points to how the commission was picked. All three commissioners were chosen under the 2023 law by a panel of the prime minister, the home minister and the leader of the opposition, the Express noted. Opposition members of that panel recorded dissents over the process in 2024 and 2025, the paper reported.\n\n## The government's case\n\nThe ruling BJP says the opposition is blaming the referee for its defeats. Shah spoke to the party's Uttar Pradesh state executive in Lucknow. He compared Gandhi and Samajwadi Party leader [Akhilesh Yadav](/politicians/akhilesh-yadav) to a team that blames the umpire after losing a match, [The Indian Express reported](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/pm-narendra-modi-banaskantha-gujarat-amit-shah-opposition-india-bloc-10944001/).\n\n\"Rahul baba, BJP is fully ready for a discussion on SIR in Parliament. Come, let's convene a special session of Parliament,\" Shah said. He accused Gandhi of not wanting Parliament to run, and said a \"mock Parliament\" outside harms its dignity. [India Today reported](https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/amit-shah-rahul-gandhi-akhilesh-yadav-vote-chori-special-parliament-session-3028668-2026-10-30) that Shah said Gandhi would not accept the offer because he wanted \"drama on the streets.\"\n\nModi spoke the same day in Banaskantha, Gujarat. \"Some people do not like this,\" he said of India's push for development. \"These are individuals who wish to see the country in difficulty.\" He accused unnamed critics of spreading fear about cooking gas and fertilizer supplies. He tied this to the crisis in West Asia, the Express reported. He did not name the Election Commission in the remarks the paper quoted.\n\n## What a 'public impeachment' can and cannot do\n\nThe October 31 event is political theater, not a legal process. The ECI's affidavit notes that a CEC can be removed only in the same way, and on the same grounds, as a Supreme Court judge. Under the Constitution, that takes a motion passed in each house of Parliament by a special majority. It needs a majority of the total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting. The opposition does not have those numbers on its own.\n\nThat leaves three tracks. The first is the court, where petitioners now have 10 days to reply. The second is the street, starting with Sunday's rally. Delhi Police plan to deploy more than 3,000 officers and over 200 cameras at Ramlila Maidan, The Hindu reported. A traders' group has asked the Congress to postpone the rally during the festival season, citing business losses.\n\nThe third is Parliament. India Today reported speculation that the government may call a special session for bills on delimitation and women's reservation. Whether the SIR would get floor time there is unclear.\n\n## Why it matters for coming elections\n\nUttar Pradesh, India's most populous state, votes in about six months. Shah said the BJP would win a third straight term there and would bring a Uniform Civil Code to the state if it does, the Express reported. The Samajwadi Party recently won five of 11 seats in state legislative council races, including both in Varanasi, India Today reported.\n\nFor more, see our [India elections guide](/elections/india), our [India issues page](/issues/india), and profiles of [Mallikarjun Kharge](/politicians/mallikarjun-kharge), the Congress president, and the other leaders named here.\n\nCampaign finance note: Indian parties file contribution and expense reports with the Election Commission. This article did not review those filings.\n\n## Photo note\n\nPhoto: Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar (center) sits with Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. The ECI was announcing the second phase of the SIR at Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi, on October 27, 2025. Election Commission of India, [original file](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:The_Chief_Election_Commissioner_(CEC)_of_India,_Shri_Gyanesh_Kumar_addressing_a_Press_Conference_by_Election_Commission_of_India_at_Vigyan_Bhawan,_in_New_Delhi_on_October_27,_2025_(1).jpg), [Government Open Data License - India](https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/Gazette_Notification_OGDL.pdf).","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/india-bloc-cec-impeachment-sir-electoral-rolls-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}