{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/eu-energy-ministers-electricity-gas-tax-network-charges-safe-october-2026","title":"Most EU energy ministers reject Commission rule to tax electricity no more than gas","description":"Governments say the tax rule needs unanimity and resist EU-wide grid-fee design. Separately, the Commission opened a €21.3 billion SAFE defense-loan call.","author":"567politics News Desk","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-30T15:30:32.141797Z","date_modified":"2026-11-06T20:40:55.570417Z","body_markdown":"Most EU energy ministers have rejected a central element of the European Commission's plan to cut electricity bills. That element is the rule that electricity should never be taxed more heavily than natural gas. Ministers met in Luxembourg on Thursday, October 29. Most governments argued there that tax rules belong in a separate law that needs every country's agreement. They also resisted giving Brussels more say over how national grid fees are designed. The Commission says its approach is legally sound and necessary to speed the switch from fossil fuels to electricity.\n\nOn the same day, the Commission opened a second call under its SAFE defense-loan program. It invited member states to apply for €21.3 billion in loans and encouraged joint purchases with Ukraine. The two decisions are separate, but both show the Commission pressing national capitals to commit money and legal powers to shared priorities. Both now depend on decisions by national governments.\n\n\n```chart\ntype: bar\ntitle: EU electricity share: current level and target\nnote: Commission’s July 17, 2026 plan. A target is not a forecast or an achieved outcome. No intermediate growth path is implied.\nsuffix: %\nsource: [According to the Commission](https://commission.europa.eu/news-and-media/news/plan-make-europe-first-electro-continent-2026-07-17_en)\n---\nMeasure | Share of energy use\nCurrent level cited by Commission | 23\n2040 target | 46\n```\n\n\n## What the Commission proposed\n\nThe tax rule is part of a draft regulation the Commission published on July 17 alongside its Electrification Action Plan. The plan aims to raise electricity's share of EU energy use from 23% today to 46% by 2040. [According to the Commission](https://commission.europa.eu/news-and-media/news/plan-make-europe-first-electro-continent-2026-07-17_en), reaching that goal could save the EU €260 billion a year in fossil-fuel imports. The Commission also says that \"electricity often costs three times more than gas.\" It argues that this gap discourages households and companies from switching to heat pumps and electric vehicles.\n\nThe draft regulation would let member states reduce network charges for certain groups of consumers and taxes for energy-intensive businesses, [the Commission's July press release says](https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/document/print/en/ip_26_1596/IP_26_1596_EN.pdf). It \"also seeks to make sure that electricity is not taxed more heavily than gas.\"\n\nA Council background note prepared for Thursday's meeting sets out the tax provisions in detail. According to [the note from the Irish presidency](https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST-14016-2026-INIT/en/pdf), dated October 14, the Commission proposed three \"ancillary taxation measures\":\n\n- Member states would adopt a taxation framework \"supportive of electricity.\"\n- National excise duties on electricity would have to be \"less than or equal to natural gas excise duties.\"\n- Power for energy-intensive businesses would count as meeting the green conditions for tax cuts. Those conditions are set in the existing Energy Taxation Directive.\n\nThe note says the Commission included these measures to avoid a \"waterbed effect,\" in which tax changes could cancel out savings from better grid-fee design. It also records the central objection. Many member states, it says, \"generally expressed support for the objective of incentivizing electrification.\" But they saw Article 113 of the EU treaties as \"the appropriate basis for this provision, requiring unanimous decision.\" Article 113 is the legal basis for EU tax rules. The note put two questions to ministers: how to apply grid-tariff principles consistently, and whether they were \"prepared to accept a compromise on the proposed taxation elements.\"\n\nThe idea has political backing at the top. At an informal summit in February, EU leaders vowed to bring energy prices down by making electricity taxation more favorable than taxation of natural gas, Euronews reported. The Council note adds that EU leaders went further on March 19. Their conclusions called on the Commission to \"urgently present targeted measures across all components of electricity prices.\"\n\n## What happened in Luxembourg\n\nMinisters' speeches \"focused almost unanimously on the proposal's legal basis and the conflict of competences over taxation,\" [Agence Europe reported](https://agenceurope.eu/en/bulletin/article/13971/4/at-energy-council-first-political-discussions-on-network-charges-turn-into-legal-tangle). Ministers pointed to an opinion from the Council's legal service on the tax article, numbered 18c. A majority of member states said it should be removed, the agency reported. According to Agence Europe, the opinion was reportedly delivered orally to a Council working party and is not publicly available.\n\n[Euronews reported](https://www.euronews.com/2026/10/29/eu-countries-push-back-against-brussels-plan-to-tax-gas-more-than-electricity) that Germany, Italy, Malta, the Czech Republic, Bulgaria, Slovakia, Finland, Romania, Croatia, Poland, Latvia, Estonia and Hungary opposed the tax provisions. These countries argued that tax policy should be handled in the long-stalled revision of the Energy Taxation Directive. That law requires unanimity, while the electricity market regulation can pass by qualified majority. Spain, Denmark and Luxembourg backed the Commission but asked for some flexibility, Euronews reported. Denmark's envoy, Søren Jacobsen, said the plan \"should include flexibility for member states to set clear political priorities for ambitious electrification policies.\" France asked for the legal basis to be secured or for the measure to be tied to a gas-supply crisis.\n\nThe concern about precedent was explicit. \"We run the risk of creating a precedent that could disrupt the energy taxation architecture,\" Cyprus's energy minister, Michael Damianos, said, [according to Rapporteur](https://www.rapporteur.com/news/capitals-stonewall-brussels-over-electricity-bill-reform/). Austria's deputy permanent representative, Franz Wirtenberger, made a similar point, Agence Europe reported.\n\nEnergy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen defended the plan. He said the approach \"makes a lot of sense\" and that legal services at both the Commission and the Council had judged it sound, Euronews reported. \"We should not deprive our consumers and industries of the benefits of this proposal,\" he told ministers. Agence Europe reported that he also assured member states he had taken careful note of their concerns, as did O'Brien. The Commission's July proposal describes the tax measures as \"purely ancillary to the primary objective\" of making the energy market work, according to Agence Europe.\n\n## The grid-fee dispute\n\nThe second fight concerns network charges, the fees consumers pay for using transmission and distribution grids. Network tariffs make up about a third of an average household electricity bill, Rapporteur reported. The Commission proposed a common tariff structure to harmonize how countries set these fees, according to the Council note.\n\nEuronews described this as the strongest opposition of the day. The Commission wants to set common rules for calculating grid charges without seeking fresh approval from member states and the European Parliament each time. Italy, France, Germany, Slovakia, Poland, Spain, Finland and other countries argued this would undermine the independence of national regulators, Euronews reported. Finland said its parliament had formally concluded that the proposal violates the subsidiarity principle, under which the EU acts only where goals cannot be met nationally. \"Member states must retain sufficient flexibility to reflect their national circumstances, investment needs and electricity systems. We are also concerned by the lack of comprehensive impact assessment,\" said Finland's representative, Mika Nykänen. Sweden's energy minister, Ebba Busch, said there was \"no one-size-fits-all solution for tariff design,\" Euronews reported.\n\nRapporteur reported that France and Germany warned that EU-designed grid fees could affect national support for heavy industry. Germany, for example, waives up to 90% of grid fees for some large users, according to Rapporteur. It also spends about €6 billion a year to hold grid fees down. By the outlet's own calculation, countries representing about two-thirds of the EU's population resist letting the EU design grid tariffs.\n\n## Proposed compromises\n\nSeveral alternatives were raised. Greek Energy Minister Stavros Papastavrou proposed a joint meeting of energy and finance ministers, an idea supported by Bulgaria, Slovakia and Romania, Agence Europe reported. Luxembourg suggested replacing the tax provisions with a general obligation for member states to promote electrification and improve the price ratio between gas and electricity.\n\nIrish Energy Minister Darragh O'Brien chaired the meeting. He wants a deal at the last energy council of Ireland's presidency, on December 10. \"I'm optimistic, not naive, these things aren't easily done,\" O'Brien said, according to Rapporteur. The [Irish presidency's summary of the meeting](https://irish-presidency.consilium.europa.eu/en/news/results-of-the-tte-energy-council-29-october-2026/) said ministers discussed the proposal and the energy security outlook for winter 2026–2027.\n\nAgence Europe noted the history behind the unanimity concern. After four years of talks, EU finance ministers had failed to agree on a revised Energy Taxation Directive by November 2025, and the then Danish presidency dropped the effort.\n\n## What outside groups say\n\n**Consumer advocates.** BEUC, the European consumer organization, supports the tax rule. \"Reducing taxes on electricity lowers bills for consumers and promotes electrification,\" it said in [its key points on the proposal](https://www.beuc.eu/sites/default/files/publications/BEUC-X-2026-089_key_points_on_Future-proofing_electricity_bills.pdf). It added that the excise-only approach means \"the impact will be limited to eight Member States,\" and urged governments to cut VAT and other levies as well. BEUC also warned: \"Governments may be tempted to raise gas taxes. Careful management is needed, as not all households can easily switch.\" It also criticized special grid fees for large users such as heavy industry or data centers. Lower costs for some users can mean higher costs for others, it argued.\n\n**Gas industry.** A [joint industry paper](https://www.eurogas.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/260923-Joint-Reaction-Paper-EAP.pdf) published through Eurogas in September said the action plan \"fails to explain the forthcoming economic burden\" for consumers who cannot fully electrify. The signatories called for network charges that are \"cost-reflective and avoid cross-subsidization between energy carriers or sectors.\" They also proposed basing energy taxes on each fuel's emissions, \"not solely on the type of energy carrier,\" which would favor renewable gases as well as electricity.\n\n## The arguments\n\nThe dispute does not fall neatly along left-right lines: both camps include governments led by parties of different political families. The positions below are grouped by argument rather than by party.\n\n**The case for the Commission's approach.** Supporters argue that taxing electricity more heavily than gas pushes consumers toward fossil fuels. That works against the bloc's climate and energy-security goals, they say. They point to the Commission's estimate of €260 billion in yearly import savings at higher electrification. They argue that leaving tax to a unanimity-based directive has already failed once, so a market regulation is the only realistic route. Consumer groups add that lower electricity taxes would cut household bills directly. This is the case made by the Commission, the governments that backed it, and, with caveats, BEUC.\n\n**The case against.** Opponents argue that tax rates are a national power under the EU treaties. Using an energy-market law to set them, they say, would weaken the unanimity rule for future tax questions. They say national grids, industrial structures and housing stock differ too much for EU-wide tariff design. Some, including Germany and France, want to protect existing relief for heavy industry, Rapporteur reported. Gas-industry groups argue that households and firms that cannot electrify would face higher costs, and that taxes should reflect emissions rather than favor one energy source. This is the case made by most of the governments in the Council, Finland's parliament and the gas sector.\n\n**What the record shows.** The Council note confirms that many governments support the goal of electrification while rejecting the legal route. The disagreement is mainly about competence and procedure, not about whether electrification is desirable. How much the tax rule would lower bills is uncertain: BEUC says only eight countries would be directly affected. This report found no independent estimate of the rule's effect on household bills, and no representative poll on it.\n\n## The SAFE defense loans\n\nThe Commission's other October 29 announcement was a second call under the Security Action for Europe (SAFE) instrument. [According to the Commission](https://defence-industry-space.ec.europa.eu/commission-invites-member-states-use-eur213-billion-under-safe-boost-defence-readiness-and-support-2026-10-29_en), the second round has an allocation of €21.3 billion and is open to all member states. It is part of the €150 billion in long-maturity SAFE loans adopted in May 2025.\n\nThe Commission encouraged governments to use the money \"to strengthen cooperation with Ukraine\" by including joint procurement with Ukraine in their investment plans. It asked them to prioritize \"air and missile defense systems, drones and counter-drone systems, and ammunition and missiles.\" It said some countries had requested lower amounts than first agreed when they submitted their plans in November 2025. All 19 participating member states have approved loan agreements, 16 have signed, and almost €13.5 billion has been paid out to 11 countries, the Commission said. It will tell governments their tentative allocations within two weeks of the submission deadline.\n\nNational debates over this money are already under way. Italy has been allocated €8.9 billion in SAFE loans, according to [Il Messaggero](https://www.ilmessaggero.it/economia/news/come_si_spenderanno_29_miliardi_dello_scostamento_la_difesa_investimenti_tecnologici_personale_obiettivo_rispettare_impegni_nato-9802243.html). Higher defense spending was one of the grievances in Friday's [general strike](/news/italy-general-strike-cost-of-living-defense-spending-october-2026).\n\n## Next steps: December talks on the electricity rules\n\nThe Irish presidency aims to reach a Council position on the electricity proposal on December 10. The European Parliament must also adopt its position before the two institutions can negotiate a final text. The SAFE call runs until the deadline set by the Commission, after which governments will learn their tentative shares.\n\nFor more on the governments involved, see our election guides for [Germany](/elections/germany), [France](/elections/france) and [Italy](/elections/italy), and our [Germany issue page on defense](/issues/germany#de-defence). For Germany's wider economic diplomacy, see our report on its [new work plan with Singapore](/news/germany-singapore-partnership-merz-wong-october-2026).\n\n**Funding and disclosure note.** The ministers and commissioners named here hold national or EU office. The EU has no campaign-finance database comparable to the US Federal Election Commission, and this report did not review national party-finance filings. It covers public positions and official documents, not anyone's financial interests.\n\nThis AI-assisted report was prepared on October 30, 2026, from Council and Commission documents and the reporting linked above. The Council legal service opinion cited by ministers has not been published. The full legislative text on EUR-Lex could not be accessed for this report. Our sourcing approach is described in the [567politics methodology](/methodology).\n\n## Photo and reporting note\n\nFile image for institutional context, not a photograph of the meeting reported here. The European Convention Center Luxembourg, where EU energy ministers met on October 29. Photo: Etienne Baudon, [original file](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:European_Convention_Center_Luxembourg,_external,_1_June_2019_1.jpg), released into the public domain. Cropped for publication.","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/eu-energy-ministers-electricity-gas-tax-network-charges-safe-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}