# Brazil's House speaker pushes mixed district voting before the new Congress is sworn in

Hugo Motta wants an amendment this year for a 2030 transition and a full mixed system in 2034. The PL and PT, the two largest benches, resist.

By 567politics News Desk · 567politics
Published: 2026-10-30T19:21:34.797278Z
Updated: 2026-11-02T19:31:40.681221Z
Canonical: https://www.567politics.com/news/brazil-chamber-mixed-district-voting-proposal-motta-october-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://www.567politics.com/news/brazil-chamber-mixed-district-voting-proposal-motta-october-2026.

Days after Brazil's presidential runoff, the speaker of the lower house wants to change how most of its members are elected. Chamber of Deputies President Hugo Motta (Republicanos-PB) spoke on October 28. He said he wants a vote this year on a constitutional amendment to adopt a mixed district system for proportional races. That covers federal deputies, state deputies and city councilors. Races for president, governor, senator and mayor would not change.

Motta's plan would phase the change in. A transition model would apply in 2030, and the full system would start in 2034, according to the [Chamber's official news agency](https://www.camara.leg.br/noticias/1314520-motta-quer-votar-sistema-distrital-misto-e-regras-para-redes-sociais-ainda-neste-ano). He also set up a cross-party working group to write new rules for campaigning on social media and digital platforms.

The two largest blocs in the Chamber are not on board. The right-wing Liberal Party (PL) and President [Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva](/politicians/luiz-inacio-lula-da-silva)'s Workers' Party (PT) both signaled resistance this week. The PT's president, however, said the party could negotiate. A constitutional amendment needs three-fifths of each house in two rounds of voting, so the math is hard without at least one of them.

## What Motta proposed

Brazil now elects deputies by open-list proportional representation. Each state is one large district. Voters pick a candidate or a party, and seats go to parties based on their combined vote. Within each party, the candidates with the most votes win the seats. A very popular candidate can therefore carry lesser-known party colleagues into office.

Under the mixed district idea, part of each state's seats would be filled in single-member districts, and part through party lists. [Folha de S.Paulo reported](https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/poder/2026/10/motta-define-com-centrao-proposta-de-reforma-eleitoral-e-quer-regular-propaganda-digital-para-conter-pl.shtml) that the plan would split seats evenly between the two. [CBN described](https://cbn.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/10/30/reforma-politica-enfrenta-resistencia-das-maiores-bancadas-da-camara-entenda.ghtml) a state with 20 seats as an example: 10 district seats and 10 list seats.

The 2030 transition is less settled. CBN said one option is a "federative model." Half the seats would go to the candidates with the most votes statewide, and half through party lists. Terra reported that the "distritão," a system in which the top vote-getters simply win, was also discussed as a transition. Folha reported there was no agreement yet on the transition.

Motta said he wants to act by constitutional amendment rather than ordinary law. That approach "brings more legal certainty and... more legitimacy," he said, [according to G1](https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/10/28/motta-diz-que-camara-vai-debater-mudanca-para-sistema-distrital-misto-e-regras-para-propaganda-eleitoral-nas-redes.ghtml). "The time has come to face this issue," he said, according to the Chamber agency.

Timing matters. Brazil's Constitution says a law that changes the electoral process does not apply to any election held within one year of its taking effect ([Article 16](https://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/constituicao/constituicao.htm)). The next general election is in 2030, so there is time. CBN reported that supporters want to finish before the new Congress is sworn in in February 2027.

## Who is backing it

Motta met on October 28 with leaders of União Brasil, PP, PSD, Republicanos, MDB, the PSDB-Cidadania federation and Podemos. G1 listed those present as including Marcos Pereira of Republicanos, Renata Abreu of Podemos, Antonio Rueda of União Brasil and [Gilberto Kassab](/politicians/gilberto-kassab) of PSD. João Campos, president of the center-left PSB, also attended. Motta said he would next meet the PT-led federation, PL, Novo, PSOL and Rede. He also planned to meet Senate President [Davi Alcolumbre](/politicians/davi-alcolumbre).

In a [column for G1 on October 30](https://g1.globo.com/politica/blog/julia-duailibi/post/2026/10/30/hugo-motta-quer-votar-sistema-distrital-misto-ainda-neste-ano.ghtml), journalist Julia Duailibi reported that PSD and MDB back the change. Their goal, she wrote, is to reduce the role of "puxadores de votos," the vote-pullers whose huge totals help elect party colleagues. She reported that just over 30 deputies in the new Congress helped elect others, and about 60 were elected with help from those surplus votes. She also reported that a cap of about 1 million votes on such transfers had been discussed as one option.

## The case for the change

Supporters argue that districts would tie each deputy to a defined area and make campaigns cheaper. That was the main argument in 2017, when the Senate approved a mixed district bill by 40 votes to 13. "The current system costs too much and under-represents too much," said its author, then-Senator José Serra, [according to the Senate news agency](https://www12.senado.leg.br/noticias/materias/2017/11/21/plenario-aprova-voto-distrital-misto-para-eleicoes-proporcionais). The bill went to the Chamber and never became law.

Supporters also say the current system confuses voters. A vote for one candidate can elect someone else on the same list. Brazilians often point to the 2010 case of comedian Tiririca, whose large vote total helped elect party colleagues. Duailibi cited that case and the 2026 total of Nikolas Ferreira (PL-MG) as examples of the effect.

On the digital rules, Motta said the goal is "parity of arms" among campaigns, G1 reported. He rejected the idea that the rules would limit speech. "Our goal is not to restrict anyone, it's not to censor anyone," he said, according to the Chamber agency. The working group has 15 days to draft a text, G1 reported.

## The case against

Opponents come from both ends of the spectrum, for different reasons.

PL leader Sóstenes Cavalcante (PL-RJ) was blunt. "We are against mixed district voting, with complete certainty," he told [Terra](https://www.terra.com.br/noticias/brasil/politica/lider-do-pl-na-camara-diz-que-partido-e-contra-voto-distrital-misto,5b5a607e3131ea78e99f368fef2f35c7b5a2lnml.html). He added that the party would comment further only after a meeting next week. Opposition leader Cabo Gilberto also said his group is against the change, CBN reported.

Folha reported that the PL will have 121 deputies and 29 senators from 2027. It framed Motta's push as a response by centrist parties to that growth. That is Folha's reading, not Motta's stated aim. Folha noted that the change would reduce the pull of the PL's biggest vote-getters. It named Nikolas Ferreira and Lucas Pavanato, who it said each won more than 3 million votes. The paper also cited [Erika Hilton](/politicians/erika-hilton) of the left-wing PSOL. She won about 1.5 million votes but helped elect no colleagues, Folha reported.

On the left, PT deputy Rogério Correia told CBN that the party's bench will oppose mixed district voting. PT deputy Maria do Rosário told [O Antagonista](https://oantagonista.com.br/brasil/pt-resiste-ao-voto-distrital-misto-e-lider-do-psol-alerta-para-coronelismo/) that the party has long backed closed party lists and opposes both pure and mixed district systems. "It is very hard for the party to change that position," she said. PCdoB leader Jandira Feghali told the outlet her party is against it too.

The PT's national leadership left a door open, though. Party president Edinho Silva told Metrópoles columnist Igor Gadelha that the PT prefers list voting but could negotiate as far as the mixed model, [as reported by Brasil 247](https://www.brasil247.com/poder/pt-defende-voto-em-lista-mas-admite-negociar-voto-distrital-misto-diz-edinho-silva/). "Beyond that, there's no deal," he said.

Tarcísio Motta (PSOL-RJ), who leads the PSOL-Rede federation, raised a different worry. He told O Antagonista that drawing the districts could "strengthen coronelismo," the old system of local political bosses, and vote-buying schemes. He said PSOL has not set a position and wants to see the details first.

The left's objection has a long record. In the 2017 Senate debate, PT Senator Lindbergh Farias argued that districts would narrow representation. "We will shrink the space for representatives who defend ideas and projects," he said. "We will strengthen a parochial logic." Critics of districts make a related point. Smaller parties and ideological candidates can win under statewide proportional rules but may struggle to win single-member districts.

Others question the process. In 2017, Senator Randolfe Rodrigues (Rede) questioned whether the change could be made without a constitutional amendment. Motta's choice of an amendment answers that concern but raises the vote threshold.

## How mixed systems work elsewhere

Mixed systems are common around the world. Germany, for example, elects part of the Bundestag in single-member districts and part from party lists. Designs differ in one key way. In some, list seats are used to correct the overall result so that each party's share of seats matches its share of the vote. In others, the two halves are counted separately, which tends to help the largest parties.

The reports reviewed for this article did not say which version Motta's group favors. That detail would shape who gains and who loses. A version with separate halves would likely reward parties that win many districts. A corrective version would keep results closer to today's proportional outcome while still giving each district its own deputy. The choice matters most for smaller parties, since district races often favor larger, better-funded ones.

## The numbers problem

A constitutional amendment needs 308 of 513 deputies and 49 of 81 senators, in two rounds in each house. The parties at Motta's first meeting are large. Even so, losing both the PL and the PT, the two biggest benches, would leave little room. CBN described the proposal as facing resistance from the largest blocs.

The digital-campaign rules may move separately, as ordinary legislation. Folha reported they follow allegations from rival campaigns that platforms favored Nikolas Ferreira's content. Those allegations have not been proven, and this article found no ruling on them. Left-leaning parties are more open on this front. Maria do Rosário said the PT agrees on the need for more transparency on social networks in elections, and Feghali backed progress on regulating platforms, O Antagonista reported. We did not find a public PL statement specific to the working group.

## What it would mean for the next Congress

The proposal would not change the Congress elected this month. Its effects would start in 2030 at the earliest. Even so, timing shapes the politics. The current Congress, not the incoming one, would vote. CBN reported the aim is to finish before February 2027, when the new members take office and the PL's larger bench is seated.

One view is that this timing gives the change a fair runway of more than three years. Another is that a lame-duck vote on rules for future elections is the wrong way to make such a choice. Both views turn on judgments about democratic process rather than on facts in dispute.

## Background and what to watch

On October 26, Lula met Motta and Alcolumbre at the Palácio da Alvorada, his official residence, according to photos posted on Lula's official Flickr account.

Three steps come next. Motta plans to meet the PT, PL, Novo, PSOL and Rede. The working group is due to draft digital rules within about two weeks. And the PL is expected to state a formal position after its meeting. For more on the country's political system and recent results, see our [Brazil elections guide](/elections/brazil), our [Brazil issues page](/issues/brazil) and our report on [state-by-state turnout in the runoff](/news/brazil-runoff-state-turnout-data-october-2026).

Campaign finance note: Brazilian candidates file campaign accounts with the Superior Electoral Court (TSE). This article did not review those filings for the people named.

## Photo and reporting note

Photo: Senate President Davi Alcolumbre, President Lula and Chamber President Hugo Motta (right) at the Palácio da Alvorada in Brasília on October 26, 2026. Ricardo Stuckert/Lula Oficial, [original file](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:26.10.2026_-_Davi_Alcolumbre_e_Hugo_Motta_-_55613262112.jpg), [CC BY-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0). Cropped for publication. Quotes from Portuguese sources were translated by 567politics.
