{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/big-bend-border-wall-supreme-court-filings-october-2026","title":"Big Bend border wall fight is fully briefed at the Supreme Court","description":"A river guide and two nonprofits asked the justices to keep a judge's halt on Big Bend wall work. The government says the judge had no power to rule.","author":"567politics News Desk","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-30T15:29:51.535311Z","date_modified":"2026-11-02T19:32:07.732923Z","body_markdown":"The fight over border-wall construction in the Big Bend region of West Texas is now fully briefed at the Supreme Court. On Thursday, October 29, the landowners and groups that won a lower-court order halting the work asked the justices to leave that order in place. The Trump administration had asked the Court on October 21 to lift it, and to go further by taking up the case and reversing the lower court without full briefing.\n\nThe case is *Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church*, No. 26A560. The [Supreme Court docket](https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26a560.html) shows that Justice Samuel Alito, who handles emergency applications from the Fifth Circuit, called for a response on October 22 and set a deadline of 4 p.m. on October 29. The plaintiffs filed on time. An immigration-restriction group filed a brief the same day supporting the government. The full Court could act at any time.\n\nAt stake is how far courts can review the Homeland Security secretary's power to set aside environmental and other laws to build border barriers quickly. Congress wrote that power in 1996 and strengthened it in 2005. According to the government, no court had ever upheld a challenge to the substance of a waiver until this one.\n\n## How the case reached the Court\n\nStarting in February, then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and her successor, Markwayne Mullin, issued three waivers covering the Big Bend Sector, according to the government's application. They relied on Section 102 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 (IIRIRA). That law lets the secretary \"waive all legal requirements\" needed \"to ensure expeditious construction\" of barriers and roads. In each waiver, the secretary found that the Big Bend area \"is an area of high illegal entry.\" The waivers appear in the Federal Register at 91 Fed. Reg. 7297 (February 17), 91 Fed. Reg. 27969 (May 15) and 91 Fed. Reg. 46939 (July 27), according to the plaintiffs' brief.\n\nThe plaintiffs are the Friends of the Ruidosa Church, a nonprofit formed to preserve a historic church in Presidio County; Danny William Miller, a Rio Grande river guide and landowner; and the Center for Biological Diversity, an environmental group. The center filed the suit in April, [the Texas Tribune reported](https://www.texastribune.org/2026/10/02/texas-big-bend-border-wall-court-ruling-injunction/).\n\nIIRIRA limits these suits. Federal district courts may hear only claims \"alleging a violation of the Constitution,\" and the only appeal is to the Supreme Court. That is why the case skipped the Fifth Circuit.\n\nOn October 2, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone in El Paso barred DHS from building barriers or doing \"ground disturbing activities\" in the Big Bend Sector \"until and unless\" it complies with the laws the waivers set aside. Her written opinion followed on October 14.\n\nCardone's reasoning turned on the major questions doctrine. That doctrine says that when Congress gives an agency power over matters of vast economic or political significance, it must say so clearly. She called it a \"constitutional … rule,\" which let her hear the claim despite IIRIRA's limit, [SCOTUSblog reported](https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/10/groups-ask-supreme-court-to-leave-lower-court-order-in-place-halting-border-wall-construction-in/). She then read the waiver power together with a neighboring provision that authorizes barriers \"in areas of high illegal entry.\" Big Bend, she found, \"comprises over 25% of the U.S.-Mexico border\" but accounts for \"between 0.3% and 2.2%\" of apprehensions. \"If the Big Bend Sector is an area of high illegal entry, so is every other sector, and the waiver authority would apply to the entire U.S.-Mexico border,\" she wrote.\n\nOn October 20, Cardone [refused to pause her order](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172902145/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172902145.78.0_1.pdf). She agreed the government would suffer \"at least some degree of irreparable harm\" without a pause. But she wrote that the plaintiffs' environmental, economic and recreational harms outweighed it. The main harm to the government, she said, was \"a temporary delay\" while she decides pending summary judgment motions.\n\n## The government's application\n\nSolicitor General D. John Sauer's [application](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26A560/430290/20261021153649084_Ruidosa_Application_Final.pdf) makes two main arguments.\n\n**Jurisdiction.** Sauer argues that Cardone had no power to hear the claim at all. The major questions doctrine, he writes, asks \"whether Congress in fact meant to confer the power the agency has asserted.\" That is a question about statutory authority. Under *Dalton v. Specter* (1994), he argues, claims that an official exceeded statutory authority \"are not constitutional claims.\" Treating them as constitutional would, in his view, erase the line Congress drew in IIRIRA.\n\n**The merits.** Even if the doctrine applied, Sauer argues, Congress spoke clearly. IIRIRA \"addresses head-on\" whether the secretary can waive laws such as the Endangered Species Act and the National Environmental Policy Act. He notes that secretaries \"issued waivers like these repeatedly for decades.\" He also argues that no court had ever sustained a challenge to the substance of a waiver before this one. He cites a 2019 ruling rejecting such a challenge by then-District Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson.\n\n**Harm and the balance of interests.** The application says the Border Patrol apprehended over 89,000 people trying to cross in the Big Bend Sector between fiscal years 2021 and 2025, \"and those are just the aliens who were detected.\" It cites growing drug seizures and says the Sinaloa and Juarez cartels operate across the border. A \"300-plus-mile gap in border defenses,\" it argues, \"would act as a dangerous magnet for cartels and other bad actors.\" Sauer points to *Trump v. Sierra Club* (2019), in which the Court allowed other border-wall work to go ahead while litigation continued. He asks the Court to pause the injunction, treat the application as a petition for review, and summarily reverse.\n\n## The plaintiffs' response\n\nThe [plaintiffs' response](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26A560/431171/20261029144652160_RuidosaStayOppSCOTUS.pdf), filed by Eric Glitzenstein of the Center for Biological Diversity, runs 40 pages, according to SCOTUSblog.\n\nIt opens by warning that a pause would let the government \"immediately resume blasting, bulldozing, road construction, and other border barrier-related construction\" in one of the most remote parts of the country. The area includes Big Bend National Park, Big Bend Ranch State Park and \"nearly 200 miles\" of the Rio Grande Wild and Scenic River corridor, the brief says.\n\n**The record.** The plaintiffs stress that the government \"declined to call a single witness\" or \"introduce any evidence\" at the evidentiary hearing. The plaintiffs presented six fact witnesses and two experts, the brief says. After the injunction, the government filed new declarations. The plaintiffs say those \"identify the apprehension of just 18 individuals over a period of years, only some of whom were alleged to have crossed in Big Bend.\" They cite Cardone's finding that the sector has the lowest apprehension rates on the southern border, \"lower than even the northern border's Buffalo Sector.\"\n\n**The government's own pause.** The brief says that after construction began, and \"following a bipartisan groundswell of intense opposition,\" DHS \"voluntarily paused construction across a vast portion of the project area for weeks.\" That pause, it argues, \"cannot be reconciled\" with the claim that emergency relief is needed now.\n\n**The law.** The plaintiffs argue that waiving \"myriad federal, state, local, and tribal laws across vast geography,\" including \"through national and state parks where border crossings are miniscule,\" is \"a truly 'extraordinary' assertion of power,\" SCOTUSblog reported. \"Whatever authority Congress delegated, it did not clearly authorize the sweeping exercise of power asserted here,\" they wrote. They argue *Dalton* stands only for the point that not every presidential action exceeding statutory authority is a constitutional violation, and that *Sierra Club* did not involve waivers.\n\n**Harm.** Citing Cardone's findings, the brief says construction would cause injuries lasting \"decades if not centuries,\" including fragmented wildlife habitat, altered water flows and damaged desert soils.\n\n## The government's supporters\n\nThe Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), which says it \"strongly believes that a continuous wall on the southern border is in America's best interest,\" filed an [amicus brief](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26A560/431187/20261029153202291_FAIR%20amicus%2026A560%20S%20Ct.pdf) backing the government. Its two main headings argue that \"the major questions doctrine is not constitutional\" and that \"the major questions doctrine is not implicated here.\"\n\n## The politics in Texas\n\nThe project has drawn opposition from both parties in Texas. In August, [the Texas Tribune reported](https://www.texastribune.org/2026/08/21/texas-big-bend-border-wall-barrier-republicans-paxton-trump/) that state Attorney General [Ken Paxton](/politicians/ken-paxton), the Republican nominee in the [Texas U.S. Senate race](/races/texas-senate-2026), said \"destroying one of our state's greatest natural treasures with unnecessary roads and barriers is not smart border security.\" His Democratic opponent, state Rep. James Talarico, had spent weeks criticizing the plans, the Tribune reported.\n\nSen. [Ted Cruz](/politicians/ted-cruz) welcomed a construction pause and said \"the tools needed to secure the border in Big Bend are likewise different than those needed in a dense urban environment,\" without condemning the project. Republican Gov. Greg Abbott said Mullin had \"committed to me that they will not be building a wall or a fence in Big Bend National Park.\" Comptroller Don Huffines called a permanent wall through the park \"one of the dumbest ideas I've heard in a long time.\" Former Land Commissioner Jerry Patterson, a Republican, called the issue \"a huge liability\" and pointed to \"a $7.5 billion fix in no-bid contracts.\"\n\nThe Tribune reported that the Big Bend Sector covers 517 of the border's 1,954 miles and accounted for 1.3% of the 237,538 apprehensions recorded across the border last fiscal year. CBP officials have repeatedly said there are no plans for a wall in the park itself, according to the Tribune. The plans include an access road and vehicle barriers in the park and 30-foot barriers on private land outside it.\n\n## Weighing the arguments\n\n**For the administration.** The government's strongest point is the text. Congress gave the secretary an explicit power to waive \"all legal requirements,\" and it limited court review to constitutional claims. If the major questions doctrine is a tool for reading statutes, as FAIR and the government argue, then a claim built on it is statutory and falls outside what IIRIRA lets district courts hear. The government also argues that an open stretch of more than 300 miles invites cartel traffic, and that Congress meant these projects to move fast.\n\n**For the plaintiffs.** The plaintiffs' strongest point is the record. The government offered no witnesses at the hearing. Its own numbers show Big Bend has the lowest apprehension rate on the southern border. And it paused construction for weeks on its own. If \"high illegal entry\" means anything, they argue, it cannot cover every mile of the border. They also note that the harm from blasting and road-building in a national park cannot be undone if they later win.\n\n### Claims to treat with care\n\nThe government's figure of more than 89,000 apprehensions covers five fiscal years across a sector of several hundred miles. The plaintiffs' figure of 18 people refers only to individuals named in the government's later declarations. Neither number alone settles whether the area is one of \"high illegal entry.\" The government's description of Cardone's order as a \"judicial usurpation\" of Congress's commands, and the plaintiffs' description of the waivers as an \"extraordinary assertion\" of power, are arguments, not findings. The legal questions remain open until the Court rules.\n\n## The Court's other immigration order this week\n\nOn Tuesday, October 27, the Court declined to restore a 2024 rule that allowed immigration judges to suspend some deportation proceedings, a practice known as administrative closure. In a brief, unsigned order issued without comment, it turned down a request from Baltimore, New Haven, Columbus and the legal-services group Centro Legal de la Raza, [SCOTUSblog reported](https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/10/court-declines-to-restore-biden-era-regulation-allowing-some-deportation-proceedings-to-be-suspe/). Texas sued over the rule in June. Within hours, the Justice Department and Texas asked Chief U.S. District Judge Reed O'Connor to enter judgment for the state, and he did so the same day. The challengers called the resulting judgment the product of \"egregious collusion.\" The government said their request improperly tried to turn a dispute over whether they could join the case into \"a far-reaching attack on the merits.\"\n\n## The calendar from here\n\nThe government may file a reply. The Court can then grant or deny the stay, and it could also act on the request to take up the case. Cardone has summary judgment motions pending, so a final ruling in the district court could come first. Our [United States election guide](/elections/united-states) follows the Texas races where the issue has surfaced, and our profile of [President Donald Trump](/politicians/donald-trump) covers his administration's border record.\n\nThis story concerns a court dispute over agency authority. The politicians quoted are commenting on it, not acting on it, so we did not include campaign-finance figures.\n\nThis AI-assisted report was prepared on October 30, 2026, from the court filings and news reports linked above.","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/big-bend-border-wall-supreme-court-filings-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}