Berlin's Left votes on coalition talks as Giffey refuses to take part and a Spiegel leak strains the alliance
Elif Eralp could become the first Left mayor of Berlin. Critics in the SPD and CDU want the talks stopped; supporters cite the September 20 vote.

Berlin's Left party (Die Linke) met in the Lichtenberg district on Saturday, October 31, to decide whether to open formal coalition talks with the Greens and the Social Democrats (SPD). If the delegates agree, the three parties plan to begin negotiating on Monday, November 2. The result could make Elif Eralp, the Left's parliamentary leader, the first mayor from her party to govern the German capital.
The vote follows a week that put the planned alliance under strain. On Thursday, Der Spiegel published internal comments in which Eralp wrote that she feared for her family's safety if she named a pro-Palestinian activist. On Thursday evening, former SPD mayor Franziska Giffey said she would not take part in the talks. Conservative leaders in Berlin and in the federal government have urged the SPD and the Greens to walk away.
Quotations from German-language sources are 567politics translations.
Source: Welt reported
Show the numbers
| Party | Vote share |
|---|---|
| Left | 25.7% |
| CDU | 18.8% |
| AfD | 16.3% |
| Greens | 14.3% |
| SPD | 12.1% |
Where things stand#
The Left won the Berlin state election on September 20 with 25.7% of the vote, ahead of the Christian Democrats (CDU) at 18.8%, the Alternative for Germany (AfD) at 16.3%, the Greens at 14.3% and the SPD at 12.1%, Welt reported, citing the dpa news agency. The Tagesspiegel described the SPD's share as its worst result in the city's history. The outgoing coalition of the CDU and SPD under Mayor Kai Wegner lost its majority.
The state returning officer's final result, confirmed on October 12, gives the new state parliament 153 seats. The Left has 45, the CDU 33, the AfD 29, the Greens 25 and the SPD 21. A majority is 77. The Left, Greens and SPD together hold 91 seats. The only other majority without the AfD or the Left would be the CDU, Greens and SPD, with 79 seats, a margin of two.
The Greens and the SPD had already voted to open talks the previous week, according to ZDF. The Left's decision was delayed by Berlin's two-week school autumn break, Welt reported.
The Left's congress opened Saturday morning, and the vote on talks was expected in the afternoon, Berlin time. The result was not available when this article was published. Party leaders expected a clear majority, according to the Tagesspiegel. Eralp told RBB Inforadio before the session: "I believe that the party will stand behind me with a very, very large majority."
What the three parties have agreed so far#
The talks would start from an exploratory paper the parties released about two weeks ago. According to ZDF and Welt, its most debated plan is to take about 160,000 apartments owned by five large companies into public ownership, with compensation. Germany's Basic Law allows such socialization, but no state has used it. Welt reported that the paper would let Berlin, which carries heavy debt, put up to €16 billion toward it. The SPD had rejected that approach during the campaign and at the federal level.
The paper also backs voting rights in local and state elections for all residents after five years in Germany, including non-EU citizens. Welt quoted the text: "We are strongly committed to introducing the right to vote and stand for election at municipal and state level, within our powers, for all people after five years of residence in Germany." It also says the city's education department would no longer cooperate with the Bundeswehr, Germany's armed forces.
Speaking at the congress on Saturday, Left co-chair Maximilian Schirmer called the socialization agreement a "project of the century," according to the Tagesspiegel live blog. He also cited a rent cap for state-owned housing companies. He said the paper was "not yet a coalition agreement" and that the Left would not get everything it wanted.
Before the exploratory talks began, the three parties also agreed on a joint declaration on antisemitism, Israel's right to exist and the protection of Jewish life. ZDF reports it is meant to be written into any coalition agreement, with sanctions for breaches that could go as far as expulsion from a parliamentary group.
All three parties plan to let members vote on a final deal. The Tagesspiegel reported that the SPD's state executive decided on a binding member vote. The Left plans a binding member ballot. The Greens plan a digital poll of members followed by a final delegates' vote.
The Spiegel report#
The latest dispute began with an interview. According to a dpa summary published by the Tagesspiegel, Der Spiegel interviewed Eralp on a Monday and sent the text to her spokesperson for approval the next day. In Germany, interviewees often approve their quoted wording before publication. The text came back with internal comments still attached.
Der Spiegel says it had asked Eralp whether she meant Ibrahim Ibrahim, an activist it described as a terror sympathizer who appeared at a Left election party in the Neukölln district. It says she answered yes, and that the approved version deleted the question and answer. One of the internal comments it quoted read: "Back then the LKA [state criminal police] advised never to name specific names. Back then it was about organized crime. Now it's about people with contacts to Hamas. I can't put myself and my family in danger for SPIEGEL. What do we do now? Cancel the whole interview?"
Ibrahim wrote on Instagram on October 11 that he "firmly rejects" the accusation of supporting terrorism and rejects antisemitism, the dpa report said.
Der Spiegel defended its decision. According to Deutschlandfunk, its cover story said that in a city where the potential next leader writes such a thing, internal security can no longer be seriously discussed. Felix Zimmermann, an editor at the left-leaning taz, told Deutschlandfunk the comments should not have been published. He said material sent during the approval process should be treated like a background conversation. Germany's Press Council has received complaints, a spokeswoman told dpa. The Left said Eralp had not filed one.
Eralp told reporters she would not comment on the report in detail. "What I can say very clearly is that I will ensure the safety of all Berliners as governing mayor," she said, according to dpa. In an Instagram video, quoted by the Tagesspiegel, she said: "Of course I worry about my family. I am a politician, but I am also a human being and a mother." Police gave her personal protection for Saturday's congress, according to security sources cited by ZDF and the Tagesspiegel. Eralp told RBB Inforadio on Saturday: "I don't feel personally threatened, but there is overall a very, very poisoned debate about me." She said she took the protection on the authorities' advice. The Tagesspiegel reported that the state criminal police still see no concrete individual threat to her, but consider a risk at the congress possible.
Giffey steps aside#
Giffey, the outgoing economy senator and a former mayor, wrote on Instagram on Thursday that the SPD's state chairs had asked her to lead the economy working group in the talks. She declined. "I did not make the decision lightly, but I have very fundamental criticisms of this alliance," she wrote, as quoted by rbb24. She listed unresolved questions "about dealing with antisemitism, the Left's relationship to Islamist networks, organized crime and supporters of terrorism, the handling of socialization, and the many promises that were made but have no financial basis in the Berlin state budget." She said the day's events had made her concerns "even bigger."
Other SPD figures were also critical. Neukölln district mayor Martin Hikel (SPD) said in an interview that he lacked "the imagination for how such a coalition can function reliably for five years," the Tagesspiegel reported. He also said any threats against Eralp and her family must be clearly condemned. Former federal health minister Karl Lauterbach told Der Spiegel: "I advise my party to distance itself from this alliance in Berlin with the Left party." Earlier this month, Welt reported, 20 SPD members of the Bundestag signed a statement raising "considerable doubt" about the Berlin Left's political reliability.
The SPD's state chair, Steffen Krach, has stood by the talks while setting conditions. He told ZDF the signal from Eralp's comments was "devastating" for police and prosecutors and that the fight against organized crime must be pressed harder, according to the Tagesspiegel. He told Deutschlandfunk: "We will hold coalition negotiations in the coming weeks. One cannot yet say whether they will be successful." He said Eralp had always spoken clearly against Hamas and organized crime in private, and "she must do that publicly too."
The case against the coalition#
Conservatives have pressed hardest. Thorsten Frei (CDU), who leads the conservative group in the Bundestag, told the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger that the SPD and Greens "must pull the emergency brake," the Tagesspiegel reported. "Nobody should have to fear for themselves and their family, and that of course also applies to Ms. Eralp," he said. He said parts of her own party were making common cause with "exactly the extremist milieu she fears." Chancellor Friedrich Merz told the CDU youth wing recently: "That is not permissible, to protect our democracy. Stop what you are on the way to instigating in Berlin," according to tagesschau.de.
Josef Schuster, president of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, told Der Spiegel that the Greens and SPD "have a duty not to hand this Left responsibility for governing Berlin, nor for the security of the Jewish community," according to dpa.
The objections fall into three groups. The first is antisemitism and extremism. Critics point to the Ibrahim episode and to Vanessa Emde, a Left member of the state parliament from Neukölln. ZDF reports Emde is disputed over her positions on the Middle East conflict and the Left's leadership sees no working basis with her. The second is policy: CDU deputy leader Günter Krings told dpa the voting-rights plan is unconstitutional, citing Article 28 of the Basic Law. The third is money, the cost of socialization in a state with heavy debt.
The CDU's state parliamentary leader, Stefan Evers, said he would invite the Greens and SPD to exploratory talks at a meeting set for November 3, according to the Tagesspiegel.
The case for the coalition#
Supporters start from the election result. Former Federal President Joachim Gauck said on ZDF's Maybrit Illner that Berliners had made the Left the strongest party and so it should govern, as summarized by ZDF. Bodo Ramelow, the Left's former premier of Thuringia, told tagesschau.de that Eralp should "absolutely" try to lead a government. He said the Left had brought issues like affordable rent into the debate. He described opposition to governing within the party as "an absolute minority position."
The Left's federal leaders, Ines Schwerdtner and Luigi Pantisano, said that publishing private content about Eralp "that acutely threatens the safety of her family goes too far," according to Deutschlandfunk. Schwerdtner told tagesschau.de the federal party is in close contact with the Neukölln branch. She said allowing those boundary violations undermines legitimate solidarity with Palestinians.
At the congress, Left co-chair Kerstin Wolter rejected claims of antisemitism, according to the Tagesspiegel. She said the party has "a special responsibility for the protection of Jewish life" in the city where the Holocaust was planned. She added that people who justify violence against civilians must be excluded from the peace movement.
Greens federal co-leader Franziska Brantner told the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger it was "very understandable that Elif Eralp is afraid," according to dpa via the Tagesspiegel. She added that "anyone who wants to act credibly must also be consistent when the relevant structures reach into their own party."
Some opposition also comes from the left. ZDF reported that the party's youth wing, Linksjugend Solid, opposes the alliance and wants "a strong socialist opposition." The Tagesspiegel reported that close to 100 pro-Palestinian activists protested outside the congress hall on Saturday against Eralp and against the Left joining a government.
What polling shows#
No Berlin-only poll on the coalition was found for this article. The most recent national measure is the ZDF Politbarometer by Forschungsgruppe Wahlen. It surveyed 1,225 eligible voters across Germany online and by telephone from October 20 to 22, according to the Berliner Zeitung. Asked about a Left-led coalition in Berlin, 56% said it would be bad, 26% good and 16% that it would not matter. Among SPD supporters, 42% rated it negatively, as did 26% of Green supporters.
The published report does not give a margin of error. By 567politics' calculation, sampling error for a simple random sample of that size would be about ±3 percentage points. The poll measures national opinion, not the views of Berlin voters. It was taken before the Spiegel report.
What to watch#
- Monday's start. If the Left approves, the three parties plan to open talks on November 2. Who leads the SPD's economy group after Giffey's refusal is unannounced.
- The CDU's November 3 meeting. Evers plans to offer the Greens and SPD an alternative. That coalition would have 79 of 153 seats.
- The Emde case. Party and parliamentary bodies are still weighing sanctions. Any coalition deal would include the antisemitism declaration.
- Federal action on socialization. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt wants a federal law to make socializing large housing portfolios harder, ZDF reported.
- Member votes. Any deal must pass ballots in all three parties.
For background on German parties and issues, see our Germany election guide and Germany issues page. Our methodology page explains how 567politics handles polls and contested claims.
Differing perspectives
Should the Left, Greens and SPD form Berlin's next government together?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Let the Left's winner try to govern
Who holds it: Bodo Ramelow, Left, Bundestag vice president and former Thuringia premier
Asked by tagesschau.de whether Elif Eralp should pursue a government despite the headwind, Ramelow said, in a translation from German: "Absolutely." He said the Left had brought issues such as affordable rent into public debate. On internal opposition to governing he said: "This debate about not governing is an absolute minority position." He said members would approve any coalition agreement in a ballot.
In their words: tagesschau.de, Oct. 31, 2026 ↗
Stay out of this alliance
Who holds it: Franziska Giffey, SPD, outgoing Berlin economy senator and former mayor
Giffey declined to take part in the talks. In a translation from German, she wrote: "I did not make the decision lightly, but I have very fundamental criticisms of this alliance." She listed unresolved questions about antisemitism, the Left's relationship to Islamist networks, organized crime, socialization and promises "that have no financial basis" in the state budget. She said events on Thursday made her concerns "even bigger."
In their words: rbb24, Oct. 30, 2026 ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Berlin's Left votes on coalition talks as Giffey refuses to take part and a Spiegel leak strains the alliance.” 567politics. Published 2026-10-31. Updated 2026-11-06. https://www.567politics.com/news/berlin-coalition-talks-spd-greens-left-giffey-october-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Berlin's Left votes on coalition talks as Giffey refuses to take part and a Spiegel leak strains the alliance |url=https://www.567politics.com/news/berlin-coalition-talks-spd-greens-left-giffey-october-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-10-31 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://www.567politics.com/news/berlin-coalition-talks-spd-greens-left-giffey-october-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Berlin's Left votes on coalition talks as Giffey refuses to take part and a Spiegel leak strains the alliance",
"URL": "https://www.567politics.com/news/berlin-coalition-talks-spd-greens-left-giffey-october-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
10,
31
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://www.567politics.com/embed/news/berlin-coalition-talks-spd-greens-left-giffey-october-2026?theme=auto" title="Berlin's Left votes on coalition talks as Giffey refuses to take part and a Spiegel leak strains the alliance by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Berlin's Left votes on coalition talks as Giffey refuses to take part and a Spiegel leak strains the alliance by <a href="https://www.567politics.com/news/berlin-coalition-talks-spd-greens-left-giffey-october-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://www.567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Final result of the election to the 20th Berlin House of Representatives ↗
Berlin State Returning Officer
Official final seat distribution (153 seats: Left 45, CDU 33, AfD 29, Greens 25, SPD 21), Oct 12, 2026.
- primary evidence
Extraordinary session of the 10th state party congress ↗
Die Linke Berlin
The Left's own congress page: Oct 31 session to assess the exploratory paper and decide on coalition talks, with motions filed.
- independent analysis
Linke stimmen über Koalitionsverhandlungen ab (live blog) ↗
Tagesspiegel
Running coverage of the congress, speeches by Schirmer and Wolter, Giffey's refusal, Krach, Frei, Brantner and Hikel comments, and member-vote plans.
- independent analysis
Nach Eralp-Interview nimmt Kritik an Berliner Linken zu ↗
Tagesspiegel / dpa
dpa account of the Spiegel report, Eralp's response, SPD, Green and Central Council of Jews criticism, and Evers' Nov 3 invitation.
- other perspective
Kritik am Spiegel wegen Veröffentlichung interner Kommunikation mit Elif Eralp ↗
Deutschlandfunk
Media-ethics debate: Spiegel's justification, taz editor's criticism, and Left leaders' and Ramelow's objections.
- independent analysis
Giffey steht für rot-grün-rote Verhandlungen nicht bereit ↗
rbb24
Berlin public broadcaster's report on Giffey's Instagram statement declining to lead the SPD's economy working group.
- right argument
Union greift rot-grün-rote Pläne für Berlin an ↗
Welt
CDU/CSU case against the exploratory paper: Krings on non-citizen voting rights, Hoffmann on the federal coalition deal, plus the 20 SPD MPs' statement.
- left argument
Die Linke in Berlin: Aus dem Trubel in die Koalition? ↗
tagesschau.de (ARD)
Features the Left's case: Ramelow backing Eralp and Schwerdtner on the Neukölln branch; also quotes Merz's call to stop.
- independent analysis
Berlin: Die Linke entscheidet über Koalitionsverhandlungen ↗
ZDFheute
Overview of the exploratory paper (160,000 flats), antisemitism declaration, Emde case, Dobrindt's planned law and Gauck's view.
- independent analysis
Berliner Linke entscheidet über Koalitionsverhandlungen ↗
Welt / dpa
dpa preview of the congress with vote shares, youth-wing opposition and police protection for Eralp.
- independent analysis
Umfrage: Mehrheit lehnt Linke-geführte Regierung in Berlin ab ↗
Berliner Zeitung
ZDF Politbarometer (Forschungsgruppe Wahlen), Oct 20-22, n=1,225 national; field method online and phone; no MOE given.
Reviewed 2026-10-31. Sources opened and read for this story on Oct 31, 2026. discover_politics_sources returned only generic Berlin pages (Wikipedia, tourism sites), so all sources were chosen by hand. Most coverage is German-language; quotes in the article are 567politics translations. Welt's Oct 19 report centers conservative (CDU/CSU) objections; the tagesschau report centers Left voices (Ramelow, Schwerdtner). No Berlin-only poll on the coalition was found; the cited ZDF Politbarometer is national. The Left congress vote result was not yet available at publication.