{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-subpoenas-dunleavy-certification-october-2026","title":"Justice Department widens Alaska Senate probe as governor links certification to state inquiry","description":"Dozens of new subpoenas, a rewritten lawsuit and a state inquiry follow a disputed report about a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot. No one has been charged.","author":"567politics News Desk","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-10-30T15:20:33.047788Z","date_modified":"2026-11-02T19:52:16.40597Z","body_markdown":"Days before Alaska's U.S. Senate election, the race between Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and Democrat Mary Peltola is now the subject of three separate government inquiries. The Justice Department has issued at least three dozen new subpoenas and document-preservation requests in a federal criminal investigation, a U.S. official [confirmed to NBC News](https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-election/mike-dunleavy-orders-investigation-mary-peltola-campaign-dan-sullivan-rcna606316) on Thursday, October 29. Gov. Mike Dunleavy has ordered a state criminal inquiry and said that, depending on its findings, certification of the result could be \"stopped or changed.\" And the House Oversight Committee has asked two people named in a New York Times report to sit for interviews.\n\nAll three inquiries concern the same allegation: that people connected to Peltola's campaign and national Democrats helped recruit a second candidate named Dan Sullivan to draw votes from the senator. Peltola, her campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) and the second candidate deny it. No one has been charged, and no court has found that the reported recruitment broke any law.\n\nThese inquiries are separate from the Justice Department's civil certification lawsuit, whose fast schedule we covered in [an earlier report on the Anchorage case](/news/alaska-senate-doj-lawsuit-certification-court-schedule-october-2026), but that suit was rewritten on Thursday to rely on the same reporting.\n\n## What prompted the new activity\n\nOn Wednesday, October 28, The New York Times published an account of what it said was an effort, internally called the \"Ballot Composition Project,\" to recruit candidates who could split support for Sen. Sullivan. According to [NBC News](https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-election/mike-dunleavy-orders-investigation-mary-peltola-campaign-dan-sullivan-rcna606316), the Times cited interviews with 12 people who were involved in or told about the plan or were approached as potential recruits, along with dozens of text messages. It named Democratic operative Jerid Kurtz as a recruiter; he did not respond to the Times.\n\nThe sourcing has a material limitation that the Times itself disclosed. Much of the account came from Elisa Rios, Peltola's former campaign manager, who was fired in August. NBC News reported that Rios later contacted the Times and \"retracted all statements made regarding the 2026 Alaska Senate Race.\" [Alaska News reported](https://alaskanews.com/c/alaska-news/doj-rewrites-its-alaska-senate-suit-and-the-state-asks-a-judge-to-toss-it-by-monday) that the Times said her interviews were consistent with its other reporting. The Times also described ballot-stacking tactics as common and \"generally considered legal,\" noting that both parties have used them in Alaska.\n\nThe second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired Petersburg teacher, has said he entered the race on his own and told the Associated Press in June that he had no contact with Peltola's campaign (\"Zero, none, zilch\"), according to [the AP account carried by NBC4 Washington](https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/politics/alaska-governor-probe-democrat-alleged-efforts-recruit-2nd-dan-sullivan/4173838/). On the general-election ballot, the senator appears as \"Dan S. Sullivan,\" identified as a registered Republican and the incumbent; the challenger appears as \"Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.\" with no party affiliation.\n\n## The federal criminal investigation\n\nAccording to NBC News, the subpoenas went to Peltola's campaign office and to Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.'s offices, seeking grand jury testimony, documents or record preservation. [CBS News reported](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/doj-subpoenas-alaska-senate-probe-ballot-sullivan-peltola/), citing multiple sources, that subpoenas were also directed to several Democratic officials believed to be tied to the recruitment effort. Alaska News reported that Reuters, citing one source, put the number above 40. None has been made public, so recipients and wording cannot be independently checked.\n\nThe investigation itself is not new: NBC News previously reported that a grand jury issued subpoenas to witnesses linked to the second Sullivan's campaign in August.\n\nAt a briefing for reporters on Thursday, a Justice Department official described a \"significant increase in activity\" in the preceding 24 hours, CBS News reported. Asked what federal crimes a recruitment scheme could involve, the official pointed to two civil rights statutes, 18 U.S.C. Sections 241 and 242. Section 241 bars conspiracies to interfere with federal rights such as voting; Section 242 covers willful deprivation of rights under color of law. The official also cited the conspiracy prosecution of Douglass Mackey over 2016 posts falsely telling Hillary Clinton supporters they could vote by text; CBS noted that an appeals court overturned that conviction in 2025.\n\nThe same official acknowledged that the department was not aware of any confirmed case of an Alaska voter mistakenly choosing the wrong Dan Sullivan. \"I think I've not heard of that, but it's hard to tell exactly,\" the official said, according to CBS.\n\nAttorney General Todd Blanche declined in a Fox News interview on Wednesday to discuss criminal investigations but accused Democrats of \"cheating.\" \"They are trying to take votes away from the incumbent, not by running an election, not by running on issues but by putting up a person with the same name,\" he said, [as reported by the AP](https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/politics/alaska-governor-probe-democrat-alleged-efforts-recruit-2nd-dan-sullivan/4173838/).\n\nThe AP noted that the department has historically avoided overt investigative steps against candidates just before an election; the official framed the new steps as a response to evidence in the Times report.\n\n## The governor's investigation and his certification remarks\n\nDunleavy, a Republican whose term ends December 7, directed the Alaska Department of Public Safety on Wednesday night to determine \"whether this scheme violated Alaska's laws and whether criminal charges or civil action are warranted,\" NBC News reported, quoting his post on X. He wrote that the evidence would determine the next steps. He called the Times account \"disturbing new evidence of an organized effort to manipulate Alaska's elections\" and said it \"substantially supports\" the state Division of Elections' earlier findings.\n\nIn a NewsNation interview on Thursday, Dunleavy would not commit to certifying a Peltola victory while the inquiry is open, [Alaska News reported](https://alaskanews.com/c/alaska-news/dunleavy-says-signing-off-on-a-peltola-senate-win-depends-on-his-investigation). He said the investigation \"may in fact impact whether somebody is seated in the U.S. Senate.\" He added: \"If we find out there's wrongdoing, and if that means that the certification then is stopped or changed, then that's what happens.\" Peltola's campaign told Axios that Dunleavy was threatening to overrule Alaska voters, according to the same report.\n\n### What the law says about certification\n\nUnder Alaska law, once the state ballot-counting review is complete, the elections director \"shall certify the person receiving the largest number of votes,\" as the statute is quoted in the [Justice Department's own amended complaint](https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/2026-10-29-DOJs-first-amended-complaint.pdf). Alaska News noted that it contains no exception for a pending investigation. The director, Carol Beecher, acts for Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom. The division aims to certify by November 25.\n\nA separate federal statute, [2 U.S.C. § 1a](https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/2/1a), makes it \"the duty of the executive of the State\" to certify a senator's election, under the state seal, to the President of the Senate. That is the governor's step, and the statute frames it as a duty.\n\nA refusal to sign could delay or complicate seating a winner, Alaska News reported, but the Constitution makes the Senate the judge of its own members' elections, and the Senate has seated members by unanimous consent before their credentials arrived. Neither the federal statutes nor Senate rules provide an automatic substitute for a governor's credential. The new Senate term begins January 3, after Dunleavy has left office.\n\n## The civil lawsuit, rewritten\n\nThe Justice Department filed a [21-page first amended complaint](https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/2026-10-29-DOJs-first-amended-complaint.pdf) in *United States v. State of Alaska* on Thursday afternoon. It keeps the original claim under the National Voter Registration Act and adds a second under the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, arguing that certifying a result shaped by the alleged scheme would frustrate Congress's election-integrity objectives.\n\nIt leans on the Times: \"Although what the New York Times reports is not always true, its reporting here aligns with what the United States has been alleging on information and belief. It also aligns with common sense,\" it says. It asserts that Daniel J. Sullivan's candidacy \"was the result of the Peltola campaign's so-called Ballot Composition Project\" and that \"the sole purpose of his candidacy is to benefit the Peltola campaign.\" These are untested allegations; the complaint cites no evidence beyond the Times report and the Division of Elections' June finding.\n\nBeecher's June 15 finding said his declaration was filed \"with a purpose to confuse or mislead\"; state courts reversed the disqualification because the division applied a \"good faith\" test found nowhere in Alaska law, without ruling on his motives, Alaska News reported.\n\nThe requested relief is essentially unchanged, [Democracy Docket reported](https://www.democracydocket.com/news-alerts/doj-seeks-to-wipe-out-bids-to-dismiss-alaska-election-case-after-amending-lawsuit/) (the outlet discloses that its founder chairs the law firm representing the Democratic intervenors). If Sen. Sullivan loses and assigning Daniel J. Sullivan's votes to him would change the ranked-choice outcome, the department wants certification barred pending an investigation into what those voters intended. Less than two hours later, the department filed a [four-page response](https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/46-2026-10-29-DOJs-opposition-to-motions-to-dismiss.pdf) arguing that the amendment made the pending dismissal motions moot: \"All three motions to dismiss … should be denied as moot.\"\n\nThe amended complaint also says Peltola's campaign committee, Alaskans for Mary, and the DSCC \"appear to have turned to misleading this Court\" in an earlier proposed answer. Judge Sharon Gleason had [allowed both groups and a coalition of voter organizations into the case](https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/2026-10-28-Order-on-motions-to-intervene.pdf) on Wednesday after the department withdrew its opposition. The court has made no finding on the misleading-the-court allegation.\n\n## The responses\n\n**Alaska's election officials.** Within hours, lawyers for Beecher and the state's election boards filed a [25-page motion to dismiss the amended complaint](https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/2026-10-29-Alaska-election-boards-motion-to-dismiss-the-first-amended-complaint.pdf) \"immediately, with prejudice,\" and asked Gleason to rule by Monday, November 2. They called the mootness filing \"gamesmanship,\" Alaska News reported. They argue the new claim rests on the same theory: that a voter registration law governs a case that \"has nothing to do with voter registration.\" They also say the requested investigation cannot be carried out, because ballots cannot be traced to voters and Alaska's constitution requires that \"secrecy of voting shall be preserved.\" These officials work under a Republican lieutenant governor.\n\n**Peltola, her campaign and the DSCC.** In their own [motion to dismiss](https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/57-2026-10-29-Alaskans-for-Mary-and-DSCCs-motion-to-dismiss-the-amended-complaint.pdf), the campaign and DSCC answered the misleading-the-court accusation in one word: \"Nonsense.\" They wrote that their earlier filing declined to admit or deny an allegation about Daniel J. Sullivan's state of mind, and that \"the only one who could possibly know Daniel J. Sullivan's true reasons for filing as a candidate is Daniel J. Sullivan.\" They called the new allegations \"a distraction\" and backed the League of Women Voters' call for the court to consider sanctions. A DSCC spokesperson told NBC News that \"the DSCC is not involved with Dan J. Sullivan\" and that Republicans \"have a long history of recruiting and propping up candidates.\" Peltola told supporters on Thursday night, \"I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent,\" adding, \"I am not interested in tricking voters.\"\n\n**President Trump, Vice President Vance and Republican leaders.** Asked about the report on Wednesday, President Trump said, \"I think they should be prosecuted,\" the AP reported. Asked Thursday whether Peltola would be seated if she won, he said, \"You're going to have to see.\" Later he said she \"actually should be removed from the ballot and prosecuted.\" Vice President JD Vance stopped short of calling for prosecution but said \"we should certainly look into whether she committed election fraud,\" according to NBC News. Senate Majority Leader John Thune called it \"a concerted effort to manipulate and to deceive the voters of Alaska.\"\n\n**Sen. Sullivan.** The senator told Fox News the reported effort was \"a secret operation\" to \"trick Alaskans,\" and said, \"We'll see if it's illegal or not,\" NBC News reported. (Background: our [Dan Sullivan profile](/politicians/dan-sullivan).)\n\n**Congress.** House Oversight Chairman James Comer, R-Ky., asked Rios and Kurtz for transcribed interviews on November 5 and 6, warning of \"compulsory process\" if they decline. His press release said the two \"plotted to rig\" the race; his letters say each was \"allegedly\" tasked with helping, Alaska News reported.\n\n## Weighing the arguments\n\n**The case for investigating.** Supporters of the federal and state inquiries argue that a coordinated plan to place a look-alike candidate on the ballot, if proven, would be an attempt to win votes through confusion rather than persuasion. They note that Alaska's own elections division concluded in June, before the Times report, that the candidacy was filed to confuse voters, and the amended complaint cites Supreme Court precedent recognizing a state interest in \"avoiding confusion, deception, and even frustration of the democratic process.\" On this view, the messages described in the Times are hard to obtain without subpoenas, and preserving evidence before ballots are separated from envelopes is prudent. A department official described the civil suit in those terms: \"I don't see this as much more than a preservation suit.\"\n\n**The case against.** Critics argue that recruiting a candidate is not itself a crime and that the department has not identified a law it could enforce. Justin Levitt, a former Justice Department official under President Joe Biden, told the AP he did not know \"what federal violations are implicated that DOJ would have jurisdiction over,\" adding, \"Sure makes it seem like the point of the investigation is to become the story.\" Stephen Richer, an election analyst for NBC News, said those involved could be in the clear if there was \"no inducement, like money or threats\" and the candidate ran \"of his or her own volition.\" NBC News noted that the Times reported no evidence that Daniel J. Sullivan was coerced. Critics add that the Mackey conviction the official cited was overturned and that the department has no confirmed example of a confused voter.\n\n### Claims that go beyond the evidence\n\nVance's remark, [reported by the AP](https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/politics/alaska-governor-probe-democrat-alleged-efforts-recruit-2nd-dan-sullivan/4173838/), that Peltola \"is trying to steal a Senate seat\" and Trump's call to remove her from the ballot treat as proven an allegation resting on a contested news report, part of whose sourcing was retracted, on which no court or investigator has ruled. Comer's \"plotted to rig\" states as fact what his own letters call alleged. On the other side, Levitt's suggestion that the investigation's point is \"to become the story\" is a claim about motive the evidence cannot confirm. Dunleavy's statement that certification could be \"stopped or changed\" describes an outcome that state law, as written, does not appear to give the governor power to produce, although his separate federal duty to sign the Senate credential is a real lever over timing.\n\n## The court calendar and certification timeline\n\nGleason had not ruled as of Thursday evening, Alaska News reported, and we found no ruling by Friday morning. Voting ends Tuesday, November 3. Open questions include who received the federal subpoenas, whether investigators obtain the communications the Times described, and whether the state inquiry produces findings before the November 25 certification target.\n\nBackground on the race is in our [United States election guide](/elections/united-states), and the broader set of deadlines this week is in our [overview of the midterms' final week](/news/us-midterms-one-week-voting-disclosures-october-27-2026). This story concerns legal and investigative actions rather than either candidate's policy record or financial interests, so we did not include campaign-finance figures.\n\nThis AI-assisted report was prepared on October 30, 2026, from the court filings and news reports linked above.","link_base":"https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-subpoenas-dunleavy-certification-october-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}