Skip to content
567politics.

Elections

Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan before Election Day

Alaska says the request is unworkable and would breach ballot secrecy, as federal prosecutors confirm a criminal probe days before the Senate vote.

By 567 Politics staffPublished Updated 12 min read

The Alaska State Capitol in Juneau. Alaska's Division of Elections opposes a Justice Department request to segregate ballots in the U.S. Senate race.
The Alaska State Capitol in Juneau. Alaska's Division of Elections opposes a Justice Department request to segregate ballots in the U.S. Senate race. · Photo: James Brooks, CC BY 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), via Wikimedia Commons ↗

The Justice Department on Friday, October 30, asked a federal judge in Anchorage to order Alaska election officials to "preserve and segregate all ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan," the Senate candidate who shares a name with Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. The department asked for a decision by Monday, November 2, the day before Election Day. Alaska's election officials answered within hours that the request is unnecessary and could not be carried out without breaking the secrecy of the ballot.

The filings are the latest step in United States v. State of Alaska (case 3:26-cv-00376-SLG), the civil suit in which the department wants the court to hold off certification if the senator loses and the second Sullivan's votes might have made the difference. Our earlier report on the court schedule explains the original complaint. Our report on the widening federal and state inquiries covers the New York Times account behind them, the subpoenas and Gov. Mike Dunleavy's state investigation. This story covers what came next.

As of early Saturday, 567 Politics found no ruling on the new request in the court record published on CourtListener. The race between the senator and Democrat Mary Peltola is one of the closest Senate contests in the country, and our Alaska Senate race page tracks it.

What the department asked for#

Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman and Assistant U.S. Attorney E. Bryan Wilson signed four related filings on Friday, as NBC News reported.

The core document is a memorandum supporting a motion for expedited discovery and a preliminary injunction. A preliminary injunction is an order issued before a case is decided. The department asks the court to require the state to keep and separate ballots that rank Daniel J. Sullivan, "and only if the result may have been impacted by the scheme to confuse voters, pending an investigation."

A shorter motion to expedite explains the rush. "These modest precautionary measures will be impossible after Election Day, so there is good cause for expedited consideration," it says. The filing does not describe how the state would separate the ballots or how a review of a paper ballot would show whether a voter was confused.

The department also wants the court to let it question two parties to the case right away: Peltola's campaign committee, Alaskans for Mary, and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC). It seeks their "internal and external conversations" about "efforts to recruit Daniel J. Sullivan to run for office."

The discovery requests#

The requests aimed at Alaskans for Mary run 18 pages. They include 21 written questions, called interrogatories, that must be answered under oath, as well as requests for documents and requests for admission. Several quote the Times article and ask for "each and every fact" behind each passage.

The requests for admission ask the campaign to admit that Elisa Rios is its former campaign manager and that she met with Jerid Kurtz, the Democratic operative the Times named as a recruiter. Another interrogatory asks about any contacts with Gerald Heikes, the fourth candidate on the Senate ballot. It quotes the Times as saying Heikes "was also recruited into the race." Heikes ran as a Republican in the August primary and received 1.1% of the vote, according to the department's own figures.

The requests ask for answers "within thirty days, or within such time as the Court may allow." A matching set for the DSCC was filed at the same time.

The department's argument#

The memorandum leans on two sources. The first is a June 15 letter from state Elections Director Carol Beecher, who found that Daniel J. Sullivan's declaration of candidacy was filed "with the purpose of confusing or misleading the electorate." The department lists her reasons. He asked to appear on the ballot as "Dan Sullivan" and as "Dan S. Sullivan," though "S" is not his middle initial. He switched his party affiliation to Republican, the senator's party, immediately before filing. And he worked with a consultant who is a longtime supporter of Democratic candidates. State courts later overturned that decision, ruling that officials lacked authority to exclude a candidate based on their interpretation of "good faith," as CBS News reported.$

The second source is the Times report. The memorandum quotes it at length. Among the quoted passages are an internal DSCC message saying "Other Dan won, will be on ballot" and a description of Peltola advisers watching a focus group. It says the Times report "further supports that (common sense) conclusion" that the candidacy was "frivolous." Citing the Times, it ties the effort to the Elias Law Group, which represents the campaign and the DSCC in this case.

On the law, the department argues that the National Voter Registration Act's stated purpose of protecting "the integrity of the electoral process" lets the Attorney General seek this relief. It relies on the Supreme Court's 1972 decision in Bullock v. Carter, which said states have an interest in protecting their elections "from frivolous or fraudulent candidacies." It also argues that the relief would not run afoul of the Purcell principle, under which courts avoid changing election rules close to an election. "The requested relief here would not change the rules of the election," the memorandum says. It calls ballot segregation "a negligible further burden" because federal law already requires officials to keep ballots for 22 months.

The memorandum predicts that "some supporters of Senator Sullivan likely will inadvertently vote for Daniel J. Sullivan." It cites polls showing a race "within one or two percentage points" but does not identify them. It offers no example of a voter who has actually been confused.

The state's answer#

Lawyers for Beecher and the state's election boards filed a four-page opposition the same day. It makes three points.

First, the state says the court should decide the pending motions to dismiss the whole case before considering an injunction, because those motions explain why the suit "lacks any merit."

Second, it says the order is not needed and could not work as described. "The Division does not destroy federal election ballots on Election Day, it preserves them for twenty-two months after the election," the state wrote. On segregation, it said ballots are "comingled in the ballot box on Election Day," so election workers cannot pull out ballots that rank one candidate "without both violating the constitutional protections for ballot secrecy and 'chang[ing] how voters may vote.'" It quoted the department's own earlier filing, which said the United States "is not asking for any change to how voters may vote." It added that "the ballots (whether segregated or not) will not reveal any voter's reasons for voting for Daniel J."

Third, it blamed the department for the time pressure. "It waited until two weeks before Election Day to file a lawsuit about issues that arose months ago," the state wrote.

Election law scholar Rick Hasen posted the state's filing under a headline calling the request "nonsensical and unworkable."

The intervenors#

Two groups of intervenors joined the state. The League of Women Voters of Alaska, Common Cause and two Alaska voters, represented by the ACLU, called the case a "frivolous, election-eve lawsuit" in their joinder. They argued that preservation of ballots "is already required by federal law." They also cited an October 28 federal ruling in a separate California case, which warned that last-minute election relief could let "either party ... create chaos for their own political purposes."

Alaskans for Mary and the DSCC filed a shorter joinder. They called the segregation request "a direct affront to Alaskans' constitutional right to a secret ballot." They also said it appears "nowhere in its Amended Complaint." On discovery, they argued that "no matter how Daniel J. Sullivan came to run or what his reasons were for running," the voter registration law does not let the department interfere with certification. "Nothing in the voluminous discovery DOJ demands could transform DOJ's frivolous claims into viable causes of action," they wrote.

The court's calendar#

U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason has already put the motions to dismiss on a fast track. In an order issued Friday, she gave the department until 1 p.m. Friday, Alaska time, to respond to the three motions to dismiss the amended complaint. The state and the intervenors may reply by noon Saturday. The department's response, which argued against dismissal, was filed Friday along with the injunction motion. The order does not address the injunction request. The judge could rule on dismissal first, as the state asks, or take up both together.

The criminal investigation, on the record#

Shortly before the filings, Heyman held a news conference in Anchorage with FBI Special Agent in Charge Matthew Schlegel and Col. Mo Hughes of the Alaska State Troopers. "We are aware of the recent New York Times reporting regarding the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, that they orchestrated a sprawling conspiracy to recruit and prop up Daniel J. Sullivan as a sham candidate, and we are taking that extremely seriously," he said, as quoted by CBS News.

Heyman said the report "has resulted in a significant surge of law enforcement assets to Alaska" and that he had assigned several attorneys to the matter. But he declined to name any law that may have been broken. "I'm not making any assumptions on whether a crime has been committed or not," he said, according to Alaska Public Media. Asked about the timing, he told CBS, "We're not escalating anything except to the extent that a new article came out," and said the inquiry had been going on "quietly for several months."

The Alaska Story, a conservative Alaska news site, reported that Heyman described the civil suit as an effort to preserve ballots. "The department is not asking … the court to declare a winner or loser or change the votes in any way," he said. He also said the department had rescinded his earlier recusal from the matter, which arose while he was being considered for a judicial nomination. He said he had not discussed either case with the White House.

How the campaigns responded#

Peltola, at a rally on Friday evening, said she was "so deeply offended by these accusations about having any involvement with anyone else's candidacy," NBC News reported. "I want fewer candidates in the primary. I'm not out soliciting more competition," she said. The DSCC has said it was "not involved with Dan J. Sullivan."

Aubrey Wieber, who leads the 907 Initiative, a progressive group that has run ads critical of the senator, attended the news conference. "It's incredible to pull all this national media together to then say nothing," he said, according to Alaska Public Media. "One could say it appears that they are trying to interfere in an election and put their thumb on the scale."

President Donald Trump said Friday morning on Kansas City radio that he does not know how the senator can win "because you're splitting up the vote illegally. I think it's a total fraud," NBC News reported. Earlier in the week, Sen. Sullivan told Fox News host Sean Hannity how he wanted supporters to fill out their ballots. "So rank me first, Sullivan, Dan S. Registered Republican incumbent," he said. "Rank the other Republican second, [Gerald] Heikes. Rank, I hate to say it, Sean, but in our screwed-up system, you rank the fake guy third." Background on the senator is on our Dan Sullivan profile, and on the president on our Donald Trump profile.

Weighing the arguments#

The case for the department's request. Supporters of the request argue that the state's own elections director concluded in June, before any news report, that the second Sullivan's filing was meant to confuse voters. If a candidate was recruited for that purpose, they say, courts should at least keep the evidence intact so that a close result can be examined. The department argues that its request is limited. It would not change how anyone votes, it would apply only if the result might have turned on the second Sullivan, and the state must keep the ballots anyway. They add that discovery is the only way to test the Times account, which relied in part on private messages.

The case against. The state and the intervenors argue that the order is either redundant or harmful. If it means keeping the ballots, federal law already requires that. If it means pulling out certain ballots on Election Day, it would expose how people voted. Either way, a paper ballot records rankings, not reasons, so separating ballots would not show which voters were confused. Critics also argue that recruiting a candidate is not the same as deceiving voters. They point out that the Alaska courts allowed Daniel J. Sullivan on the ballot, and that the ballot labels the senator as the "registered Republican incumbent." They also say the department chose the timing by waiting to sue until early voting had begun.

Claims that go beyond the evidence#

Heyman's description of "a sprawling conspiracy" restates the Times report rather than any finding by a court or grand jury. No charges have been announced. The department's prediction that some of the senator's supporters "likely will inadvertently vote" for the other Sullivan is a forecast. The filing offers no evidence that it has happened. Trump's "total fraud" claim treats as settled a question no investigator has answered. On the other side, Wieber's suggestion that federal officials are trying to "interfere in an election" is a claim about motive that the record cannot confirm. The campaign's description of the suit as "frivolous" is a legal argument that the court has not yet accepted.

What to watch#

Replies on the motions to dismiss are due at noon Saturday, Alaska time. The department wants rulings on the injunction and discovery by Monday. Voting ends Tuesday, and the state aims to certify by November 25. If no candidate wins a majority of first-choice votes, the last-place candidate is eliminated first. Only in later rounds would rankings for Daniel J. Sullivan or Heikes be transferred, so the size of the margin will decide whether this dispute matters at all.

Turnout context is in our report on early voting in Senate battlegrounds, and the national picture is in our United States election guide. This story concerns court filings and an investigation rather than either candidate's policy record or finances, so it does not include campaign-finance figures.

This AI-assisted report was prepared on October 31, 2026, from the court filings and reporting linked above.

Differing perspectives

Should a court order Alaska to preserve and segregate ballots that rank the second Dan Sullivan?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • No injunction is needed to preserve ballots

    Who holds it: Alaska Division of Elections (Director Carol Beecher), election boards and ballot counting review board

    In an Oct. 30 filing, the state defendants said "neither expedited consideration nor a preliminary injunction is necessary to preserve ballots," because the division keeps federal election ballots for 22 months. They said election workers cannot segregate ballots without "violating the constitutional protections for ballot secrecy," and that the ballots would not reveal why any voter ranked Sullivan. They asked the court to rule on the motions to dismiss first.

    In their words: U.S. v. State of Alaska, D. Alaska, Dkt. 72, Oct. 30, 2026 ↗

  • Preserve and segregate ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan

    Who holds it: U.S. Department of Justice

    In an Oct. 30 filing, the Justice Department said "there is a substantial risk that Mr. Sullivan's sham candidacy will mislead voters." It asked for an order directing the state to "preserve and segregate all ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan" so it could investigate whether the rankings reflected voter confusion, saying these "modest precautionary measures will be impossible after election day." It asked the court to decide by Nov. 2.

    In their words: U.S. v. State of Alaska, D. Alaska, Dkt. 70, Oct. 30, 2026 ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan before Election Day.” 567politics. Published 2026-10-31. Updated 2026-11-02. https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-segregate-sullivan-ballots-peltola-october-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan before Election Day |url=https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-segregate-sullivan-ballots-peltola-october-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-10-31 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-segregate-sullivan-ballots-peltola-october-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan before Election Day",
  "URL": "https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-segregate-sullivan-ballots-peltola-october-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        10,
        31
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://www.567politics.com/embed/news/alaska-senate-doj-segregate-sullivan-ballots-peltola-october-2026?theme=auto" title="Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan before Election Day by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan before Election Day by <a href="https://www.567politics.com/news/alaska-senate-doj-segregate-sullivan-ballots-peltola-october-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://www.567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-10-31. Primary sources are the Oct. 30, 2026 filings in United States v. State of Alaska (D. Alaska No. 3:26-cv-00376-SLG) retrieved from CourtListener. Automated discovery returned only unrelated results; sources were found by direct search and read in full. The Justice Department's opposition to the motions to dismiss (Dkt. 67) is an image-only PDF and was not relied on beyond passages quoted in other filings. No court ruling on the injunction request was found as of Oct. 31 morning.

All 567politics news →